What we know
Joe (J. J.) Pettigrew's ranch, taken up in 1870: von Ahlefeldt has him coming from New York City that year, and Lavelett has his friend Patrick Murphy, already homesteading nearby, walk to Fort Bent to bring him (S-0009 pp. 26-27; S-0011 pp. 96-97). The library's record dates it to 1869 as a joint Murphy-Pettigrew homestead, the outlier; Murphy's own place is mapped separately. The survey found log cabins and a two-story house of about 1880, and a one-room schoolhouse that may have served Gwillimville (PPLD records of survey B35). In 1979 his Victorian ranch house, with a winding mahogany staircase, stood boarded up along Highway 83 'about a mile south of Pat Murphy's homestead', with a 'hanging tree' on the ranch. He gave the land for the Gwillimville church of 1893 (von Ahlefeldt pp. 26-27, 45). Cora Deane Younger added that its staircase was made in Denver and brought out by Pettigrew, and that by 1993 children called the empty house the haunted house (DCL oral history doh/827, S-0213).
People
- James J. Pettigrew (1855–1933): lived on the family ranch about 1870-84 and 1890-1933, by Koch
- Joseph Pettigrew (1826–1901): his ranch from 1870; patents 1873-95
Where it was
'Three miles south of East Palmer Divide Avenue along Highway 83' (PPLD records of survey photos B35), measured along Highway 83 in OpenStreetMap and placed on the east side of the highway: in 1993 Penny Burdick described 'that big house on the east side of 83 as we're goin' into Colorado Springs' and Cora Deane Younger identified it as the Pettigrew place (DCL oral history doh/827, S-0213). the 1987 Black Forest Preservation Plan's Map 2 No. 3 sits at the earlier point, 0.07 mile west, across the highway. Joseph Pettigrew's patents of 1873-95 are in the SW1/4 of Sec. 15 and the NW1/4 of Sec. 22, T11S R66W, around this point (GLO, S-0080; no 'J. J.' on any card). Good to about a quarter mile.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0009: Judy von Ahlefeldt, Thunder, Sun and Snow: The History of Colorado's Black Forest (Colorado Springs: Century One Press, a division of Graphic Services, Inc., 1979)
- S-0011: Lucille Lavelett, Through the Years at Monument, Colorado: The Story of Monument, Colorado, 5th printing (Palmer Lake: Palmer Lake Historical Society, 2004); first published Colorado Springs: Valliant Press, 1975
- S-0017: Pikes Peak Library District, Regional History & Genealogy
- S-0046: Douglas County Libraries, Archives & Local History: "Douglas County Timeline," "Douglas County Historic Sites," "Douglas County Schools Overview" (research collection PDFs 2, 7, 6)
- S-0050: Black Forest Preservation Plan, chapter 2, and Black Forest Community Club history (Anna Mae Hawkins, 1986), as posted on dawog.net
- S-0080: General Land Office land patents, Bureau of Land Management (glorecords.blm.gov)
- S-0101: Elaine Freed and David Barber, Historic Sites & Structures, El Paso County, Colorado ([Colorado Springs]: prepared for the El Paso County Land Use Department, [1977]), 56 pp., with the survey photographs in PPLD's Historic Sites and Structures collection
- S-0103: OpenStreetMap extracts via the Overpass API (2026-10-05)
- S-0213: Douglas County Libraries, Archives & Local History, digital archive (archives.dcl.org, CONTENTdm cdm17197): item records of all 15 collections
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.
1976 survey photographs
Taken for Elaine Freed and David Barber's survey of El Paso County's historic sites and held by the Pikes Peak Library District. The links open the library's records.