Palmer Divide Research Project

James J. Pettigrew (1855–1933)

Son of Joseph Pettigrew who came to the Divide with his family about 1870 and lived 63 years on the Pettigrew ranch on what is now Highway 83; probably the 'J. J. Pettigrew' of von Ahlefeldt's history.

Also: J. J. Pettigrew · Jim Pettigrew · James Pettigrew

PeopleEl Paso County

Biography

James J. Pettigrew was born in 1855, when his father Joseph's family was living in New York; about 1870 the family was at Fort Bent, and from there they came to the Divide, where his father homesteaded (Koch, S-0197, p. 114). Von Ahlefeldt's 'J. J. Pettigrew,' an Irishman and friend of Pat Murphy who 'came from New York City in 1870,' is probably he, by the initials, though the arrival fits his father equally; her 'handsome Victorian ranch house' with a winding mahogany staircase stood boarded up in 1979 along Highway 83, about a mile south of Murphy's homestead, and she prints photographs of the ranch after 1890 and of its legendary 'hanging tree' (von Ahlefeldt, S-0009, pp. 26-27). She credits J. J. Pettigrew with the land for the Gwillimville church of 1893 (p. 45), which Lavelett gives to Joe (Lavelett, S-0013, p. 3).

He married Matilda Smith in 1884 and moved to Idaho; after her death there in 1888 he came back to the family homestead in 1890, and in 1906 he married Anna Barry of Colorado Springs. He died in 1933, aged 77, having lived 63 years of his life on the family ranch east of Monument (Koch, S-0197, p. 114). The 1976 county survey photographed the gravestone of James J. Pettigrew (1855-1933) and Anna Pettigrew (1869-1946) in the Monument Cemetery (PPLD record of the survey photograph, S-0101). Find a Grave lists the same stone at the Monument Cemetery, James J. Pettigrew, 1855-1933 (memorial 34025610, S-0440).

Jim Pettigrew's family was among the charter members of Monument's Catholic church, built in 1911 (Lavelett, S-0011, p. 84). When Murphy left his 1,100-acre ranch, at 101, he made his home for a while with 'Mr. and Mrs. James Pettigrew' before going to St. Francis Hospital (S-0011, p. 98); Koch instead has him going to live with Joe Pettigrew (S-0197, p. 112). A photograph of about 1900 shows Murphy and his 'partner James Pettigrew' on the daily milk run to the Spring Valley Creamery (Castle Rock Writers, S-0261, p. 33); Lavelett and the Palmer Lake Historical Society caption the milk-hauling picture with Joe Pettigrew (S-0011, p. 98; S-0021, p. 35).

Places

Family

Sources

  • S-0197: Susan E. (Steppler) Koch, The Land Is In My Blood: The History of The Divide Country and Its Pioneers, complete with Driving Tour and Homestead Maps (self-published; copyright 2015, U.S. Copyright Office TXu 2-251-186; first printing 2008, second October 2015, this copy the third printing, fall 2018)
  • S-0009: Judy von Ahlefeldt, Thunder, Sun and Snow: The History of Colorado's Black Forest (Colorado Springs: Century One Press, a division of Graphic Services, Inc., 1979)
  • S-0013: Lucille Lavelett, Monument's Faded Neighboring Communities and Its Folklore: Pring, Husted, Gwillimville, Table Rock, Spring Valley, Greenland (Colorado Springs: printed by ABC Printing, 1979), 70, [40] p., illus., map, facsims.; page numbers cited are those of the third printing (Palmer Lake Historical Society, 2026), which is paged differently from the 1979 printing
  • S-0101: Elaine Freed and David Barber, Historic Sites & Structures, El Paso County, Colorado ([Colorado Springs]: prepared for the El Paso County Land Use Department, [1977]), 56 pp., with the survey photographs in PPLD's Historic Sites and Structures collection (online)
  • S-0440: Find a Grave (findagrave.com), grave memorial pages, cited by memorial number (online)
  • S-0011: Lucille Lavelett, Through the Years at Monument, Colorado: The Story of Monument, Colorado, 5th printing (Palmer Lake: Palmer Lake Historical Society, 2004); first published Colorado Springs: Valliant Press, 1975
  • S-0261: Castle Rock Writers, Douglas County (Images of America; Charleston, S.C.: Arcadia Publishing, 2017; introduction by Shaun Boyd; ISBN 978-1-4671-2652-6)
  • S-0021: Palmer Lake Historical Society, Communities of the Palmer Divide (Arcadia Publishing, March 2011)
  • Find a Grave, memorial 34025610

Every fact above names its source; numbers such as S-0246 refer to our source list. Find a Grave memorials are compiled by volunteers and are matched here only where their dates or family agree with the sources we have read.

Know more about James J. Pettigrew?

Corrections, family stories, photographs, deeds, letters and maps are all welcome. Messages and files come to Michael Christensen privately; nothing appears on the site until it has been checked, and you'll be credited the way you ask.