What we know
The only mill on the line in 1866, 11.4 chains (about 750 feet) east of the People's Fort. Olive Oakes put her husband's fort 'about twenty-five yards to the south of D.C.'s sawmill' (as summarized on a draft panel, Larkspur binder 4, p. 378, S-0005); the survey's spacing is wider. From April 1861 Oakes advertised 'Lumberton Mills, Plumb Creek,' with two mills able to cut 20,000 feet of lumber a day (Rocky Mountain News, via S-0199); the First Colorado camped 'on Plum creek near Oaks' mill' in late Feb. 1862 (News, March 1, 1862, via S-0199); and Sarah Coberly 'laid out a townsite by Mr. Oake's sawmill. There was a block house built there' (the Larkspur Historical Society's 'Our Pioneers,' p. 15, S-0199). Stone (1918) says Oakes sold his mill to Ephraim Blake in May 1865 (S-0193, vol. 2 p. 615), so the mill on Pierce's survey of June 1866 was probably Blake's; whose mill this was is not settled. The Plum Creek flood of May 19, 1864 washed away Joseph Bennet's house, which 'stood on a knoll, at least twenty five feet above the bottom of the creek,' at Oakes's mill, and drowned the Tyson family two miles below; the mill itself stood in November 1865, when Witter saw it beside the Half-Way House (Perkins, D. C. Oakes, S-0316, pp. 148-149, 178). H. L. Pitzer remembered Oakes's sawmill on East Plum Creek in the summer of 1863 and 'a sawmill near by' the Bennets whose men gave the alarm in the 1864 flood, and wrote that by about 1872-73 'D. C. Oakes's saw-mill had eaten up all the timber and was gone' (Pitzer, Three Frontiers, 1938, S-0327, pp. 148, 158, 215): a recollection, but it agrees with Witter and the 1866 survey that the mill outlived the flood. Joseph Bennet was Hiram P. Bennet's younger brother, born in 1831, and D. C. Oakes was their cousin (Leyendecker, ed., Hiram Pitt Bennet, 1988, S-0408, pp. 22, 47, 127 n. 46).
People
- Joseph F. Bennet (1831–1900): his house at Oakes's mill was swept away in the flood of 1864
Where it was
General Land Office field notes, T9S R67W (Pierce, 1866), p. 93: '51.50 Saw mill 2 ch N. of line' between Secs. 21 and 16, 1.4 chains west of Plum Creek (Larkspur binder 1 p. 120). 51.50 of 80.20 chains along the section line, 2 chains north; good to about a hundred feet.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0005: Larkspur Historical Society, "Historical Site Survey Binders"
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0045: Larkspur Historical Society website (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org)
- S-0080: General Land Office land patents, Bureau of Land Management (glorecords.blm.gov)
- S-0193: History of Colorado, illustrated, vols. 2-4, biographical (Chicago: S. J. Clarke Publishing Company, 1918 [vols. 2-3] and 1919 [vol. 4]), the set edited by Wilbur Fisk Stone
- S-0199: Larkspur Historical Society, the document store behind its "LHS Search Agent" (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org/resources/lhs-search-agents/): 362 files, about 810 MB, uploaded April–June 2026
- S-0316: LaVonne J. Perkins, D. C. Oakes: Family, Friends & Foe (Stony Ridge Press, 2009; second edition 2011), 354 PDF pp. (printed pp. 1–352 approx.), ISBN 978-0-578-01602-3
- S-0327: Henry Littleton Pitzer, Three Frontiers: Memories, and a Portrait of Henry Littleton Pitzer as Recorded by His Son, Robert Claiborne Pitzer (Muscatine, Iowa: The Prairie Press, 1938), 5 p.l., 13–242 pp.
- S-0408: Liston E. Leyendecker, ed., with Conrad Woodall, Holley R. Lange and Susan L. Hoskinson, Hiram Pitt Bennet: Pioneer, Frontier Lawyer, Politician (Denver: Colorado Historical Society, 1988; Monograph 2)
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.