What we know
Sarah Coberly's house at Huntsville, beside the People's Fort. Scott dates her stop here 1864-69, after a first stop on Spring Creek (S-0106). Her obituary says that for some years she ran a hotel on the road from Denver to Pueblo 'on East Plum creek' (Castle Rock Journal, Feb. 25, 1898), and in 1906 the same paper recalled that in the early 1860s she 'ran the hotel and stage station on east Plum creek state road (about eight miles south of where Castle Rock now stands)' (March 9, 1906). She married William M. Crull on May 7, 1865 'at residence of Sarah M. Coberly in town of Huntsville' (county marriage record), the house the family's records call Coberly's Halfway House, and in 1865 Elizabeth Field, later Mrs. John Kinner, was indentured to her there. Early in 1868 soldiers 'snowed in near Coberly's ranch, on Plum Creek' ran out of rations, and six deserted with twenty-one government horses and mules (Daily Register Call, Central City, April 9 and 14, 1868). On July 24, 1869 the Crulls sold 'the old Half Way House operation at Huntsville' to George W. Blodgett (deed book A, p. 397, as abstracted in the family's records), and the 1870 census found them in Denver (all via S-0199). Scott says the house kept the name 'Coberly House' on the Denver & Rio Grande's map of 1871 (S-0106). William Crull kept the Huntsville post office here from 1866 (Jackson, via S-0123). The Larkspur Historical Society's Google Earth map marks this as 'Coberly Halfway House #2'; its #1 matches our 'Coberly-Crull Spring Creek ranch (1863-about 1882)', which the family bought in 1863 and which may or may not have been an earlier stage stop. Perkins's biography of Oakes gives two contemporary records that put Sarah Coberly's hotel at Huntsville by 1862: a federal license list assessed by Charles F. Parkhurst, which lists 'Coberly Sarah, Huntsville, Hotel 7th class' beside Oakes's retail license there, and the News's 'Mrs. Coberlys 38 miles from Denver' (January 1862); Olive Oakes's letter of April 1862 names the Coberlys among their three near neighbors at Huntsville, and the legislators breakfasted at Mrs. Coberly's in July 1862 (Perkins, D. C. Oakes, S-0316, pp. 124-130, 140). In November 1865 the correspondent Daniel Witter found 'Coberlys, or rather Mr. Mays, the popular halfway house' on the road just before Oakes's sawmill (p. 178); the family's history says Sarah left Mays in charge when she took up land in Sec. 16 in the fall of 1864 (Carroll Coberly, mss 125, recollection; p. 151). Those records weigh against Scott's Spring Creek stage stop of 1858-64. Pvt. Romine Ostrander's diary makes the house the first night out of Denver: 'Cobely's Ranche thirsty seven miles' from Denver and thirty-three more to Colorado City on April 6-7, 1863, and the same on Aug. 25-26, when a paymaster's wagons went ahead 'with orders to go on to Cobelies.' On March 31, 1865 his detachment camped 'about one and a half miles beyond the Widdow Coberlies,' and about a dozen of them ate in the house (Malkoski, This Soldier Life, S-0324, pp. 12, 42, 96). Those distances fit Huntsville better than Spring Creek (our reading). About Dec. 20, 1864, driving north the horses taken at Sand Creek, A. K. Shaw's party 'only got up to Mrs. Culberinie's place the first day,' and he gave her daughter 'Hersey' a pinto pony (Luella Shaw, True History, 1909, S-0334, p. 134); that this was Mrs. Coberly and Hersa Coberly is our reading. Marr has seven men passing 'the hotel being built by Mrs. Coberly' at Huntsville in December 1860 (the Douglas County News of July 8, 1876, as quoted by Marr, S-0185, p. 199; the date may be the 1976 reprint), and H. T. Weibling, who carried the first government mail from July 4, 1860, recalling in 1933 that his stage stopped overnight at Coberly's 'on the east branch of Plum Creek just over the divide' (p. 182). The News of Sept. 16, 1864 gave 35 miles from Denver to Coberly's, 9 more to the top of the Divide and 24 to Colorado City (p. 197), which fits Huntsville better than Spring Creek (our reading); the Krull ranch's red barn later made the place a landmark (p. 182). From the Coberly manuscripts Marr has Sarah's husband James killed in 'the battle of Frankstown in 1864' before she married William Krull (p. 186); his fate is still open. George W. Blodgett, who bought the house from the Crulls on July 24, 1869, became Huntsville's postmaster on Aug. 9, 1869, sixteen days later (Bauer 2003, S-0391, p. 10; S-0392, p. 44), so the office went with the house (our reading). That backs Jackson's William Crull keeping the office here from 1866: Bauer has Crull appointed on Jan. 15, 1866. On Saturday, Feb. 20, 1864 the Mint's superintendent, Gen. Lane, went down to Colorado City and 'took the Coberly route, while his son and party came by the stage route' (Daily Commonwealth, Feb. 22, 1864, S-0411): that winter the road by Coberly's was a known way south, distinct from the stage road (our reading). Marr's columns put the Half-Way House at a private home of 1969-74 in the Perry Park valley, and in 1969 wrote that part of the Coberlys' first home survived in that house (Douglas County News, June 26, 1969; Aug. 10, 1972; March 14, 1974; S-0438). She put Perry's house of 1873 'in the open hayfield a bit west and north' of it (April 19, 1973), which keeps the two sites apart. That home's site has not been found.
Where it was
Pin in the Larkspur Historical Society's Google Earth version of the county map ('DC Resources,' Stage Stop folder), read from the feature's card on screen, 2026-10-07 (S-0123). Scott places the Coberlys' second site in the S1/2 of Sec. 16, T9S R67W, beside the People's Fort (S-0106); this pin is 0.3 mile from the Crull-Hammond cabin. Good to about a quarter mile.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0044: Books to borrow on the Internet Archive (controlled lending, in copyright)
- S-0045: Larkspur Historical Society website (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org)
- S-0106: Glenn R. Scott, Historic Trail Map of the Denver 1° × 2° Quadrangle, Central Colorado (USGS Miscellaneous Investigations Series Map I-2639)
- S-0123: Douglas County Historic Resource Map (Douglas County Community Planning and Sustainable Development, the Douglas County History Research Center of Douglas County Libraries, and the Douglas County Historic Preservation Board, 2012), as put on Google Maps and Google Earth by the Larkspur Historical Society
- S-0185: Josephine Lowell Marr, Douglas County: A Historical Journey (1983)
- S-0199: Larkspur Historical Society, the document store behind its "LHS Search Agent" (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org/resources/lhs-search-agents/): 362 files, about 810 MB, uploaded April–June 2026
- S-0316: LaVonne J. Perkins, D. C. Oakes: Family, Friends & Foe (Stony Ridge Press, 2009; second edition 2011), 354 PDF pp. (printed pp. 1–352 approx.), ISBN 978-0-578-01602-3
- S-0324: Paul A. Malkoski, annotator, This Soldier Life: The Diaries of Romine H. Ostrander, 1863 and 1865, in Colorado Territory (Colorado History no. 13; Denver: Colorado Historical Society, 2006), xii + 130 pp., ISBN 978-0-942576-51-1
- S-0334: Luella Shaw, True History of Some of the Pioneers of Colorado (Hotchkiss, Colo., 1909)
- S-0391: William O. Bauer, Post Offices of Douglas County, Colorado (Unadilla, N.Y.: the author, 2003), typescript, 19 pp.
- S-0392: William H. Bauer, "Colorado Postal Encyclopedia: Douglas County," Colorado Postal Historian 19, nos. 1 and 2 (2003; no. 2 is December 2003, whole no. 72), pp. 9–80 (journal of the Colorado Postal Historical Society, ISSN 0887-1663)
- S-0411: "Mint Robbery / Capture of Clark!", The Daily Commonwealth (Denver), Feb. 22, 1864 (CHNC)
- S-0438: Josephine Lowell Marr ("Mrs. John Marr"), local-history columns in The Douglas County News (Castle Rock), 1967–1976: "Douglas County History," "If Walls Could Speak" and "Walk With Our Pioneers," with the old newspaper items she reprinted (CHNC)
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.