What we know
One-story saloon (128) and barber shop (127), on both Sanborn maps (S-0147). Probably Henry Limbach's: Lavelett's photo of about 1917 shows 'Burrell's Billiard Hall formerly Limbach's Saloon & Barbershop' on Front Street next to the Walker building (S-0011, pp. 37, 57), with 'a narrow one-way passage between Limbach's saloon and Rod Walkers store' (p. 140). Limbach is the saloonkeeper in the 1884, 1886 and 1888 directories (pp. 27-29). Lavelett says two men were shot and killed in this saloon in separate incidents (pp. 55-56; a photo caption has Rube Pribble 'later shoot-kill his best friend at Limbach's Saloon'): on Oct. 21, 1876 Daniel Davidson shot Francis Brown after a feud over cattle, and Brown's stone in the Monument Cemetery reads 'He was killed'; Davidson was convicted in 1877 and acquitted at a second trial in February 1880 (p. 56). The maps name no owners. The Gazette's front page of Sunday, Feb. 21, 1909 dates the second killing and confirms the saloon. During a quarrel 'over the possession of an old plow,' Rube Pribble, 'a middle-aged ranchman,' shot William A. Neff, 34, a Colorado Springs man who had been leasing the Gwillim ranch, 'in Limbach's saloon at Monument' about 7:30 the evening before. Neff had won the plow 'by legal action through Justice A. Curry, who is also mayor of Monument.' When Pribble called him a liar, Neff, 'weighing nearly 200 pounds,' set about thrashing him, and Pribble drew a revolver; Neff died within minutes. Pribble ran out the back door to his horse and rode for his ranch, with Marshal John Spargo's posse and the sheriff's deputies after him (S-0218). At his trial in July 1909 Pribble (spelled Prebble in the Gazette) testified that his mind 'became blank after second round of drinks' with Neff and Sam Stamm. The bartender, J. F. Brandt, and Stamm said he left the saloon refusing to give up his revolver, and officers said he put a plank against his door when they surrounded his house near Monument. O. J. Curry, Monument's justice of the peace, carried Neff's body from the saloon to a hotel and kept it there overnight until the coroner came, and two farmers said Pribble had threatened Neff earlier in a dispute over the price of a load of hay. On Sunday, July 18, the jury found him guilty of second-degree murder and recommended the extreme penalty, which meant life imprisonment; its first ballot had stood eight for first degree and four for second (Gazette, July 17 and 19, 1909, front pages, PPLD scans; S-0218). The Historical Society's walking tour has Limbach's saloon and barbershop at today's 230 Front Street, about 1869, 'the focal point of the village for decades' (S-0235).
People
- Francis M. Brown (1839–1876): the shooting is placed at Limbach's on Front Street
- Daniel Davidson (active 1876–1886): the 1876 shooting is placed at Limbach's on Front Street
- Henry Limbach (1842–1918): probably his saloon and barbershop
Where it was
127 and 128 Front Street, just north of the stone store, on the Sanborn Fire Insurance Map of Monument, sheet 1, Nov. 1895 and Oct. 1900 (Library of Congress, S-0147); placed by fitting the sheet to today's Front, Washington and Jefferson street crossings at 1st and 3rd streets (six points, each within about 15 feet of the fit). Good to about a hundred feet.
Sources
- S-0011: Lucille Lavelett, Through the Years at Monument, Colorado: The Story of Monument, Colorado, 5th printing (Palmer Lake: Palmer Lake Historical Society, 2004); first published Colorado Springs: Valliant Press, 1975
- S-0017: Pikes Peak Library District, Regional History & Genealogy
- S-0147: Sanborn-Perris Map Co., Monument, El Paso County, Col., fire-insurance maps, sheet 1, November 1895 and October 1900 (Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division, Sanborn Maps collection)
- S-0218: Pikes Peak Library District, Digital Collections (digitalcollections.ppld.org): sweep of 2026-10-14 (Pikes Peak NewsFinder index records; photograph, map and oral-history records)
- S-0235: Palmer Lake Historical Society, "Palmer Lake Walking Tour" and "Monument Walking Tour" web pages (palmerdividehistory.org, about 2020-2023; removed; Internet Archive captures)
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.