Palmer Divide Research Project

Reynolds gang shot (Sept. 1864)

Reynolds gang shot (Sept. 1864) is a historic site in Douglas County, Colorado, on the Palmer Divide, listed here under murders, lynchings and killings.

Also: the Reynolds guerrillas

Murders, lynchings and killingsHistoric or vanishedDouglas County

What we know

Captured members of Jim Reynolds's band of Confederate irregulars, who had robbed the Buckskin coach in South Park that July, left the Denver jail on Saturday, Sept. 3, 1864, under Capt. Theodore Cree's Company A, 3rd Colorado Cavalry, bound for Fort Lyon (Rocky Mountain News, Sept. 5, 1864); Cree had sat on the military commission that tried them. Accounts of their deaths disagree. The News of Sept. 9 printed the soldiers' version: 'at the old Russellville townsite,' a few miles beyond the California Ranch, the prisoners tried to escape while the guard watered its horses and were 'all instantly killed.' Frank Hall, who had ridden with the posse, called that story 'an absurdity' in 1889. D. J. Cook's Hands Up (1897), from the survivor John Andrews, says the column camped at Russellville; the next morning Sgt. Abe Williamson, the driver of the robbed coach, marched six prisoners 'about five miles from camp' to an abandoned log cabin and had them shot blindfolded. Andrews, shot through the chest, lived. In 1958 Josef Winkler said George Engl's widow had shown him where Engl found the remains, on the old Engl ranch south of Franktown, and a state marker was proposed there (Douglas County News, 1958); even then, the paper said, the exact location was still being sought. Three later accounts also say execution: J. F. Meline's guide in July 1866 showed him 'the spot where the notorious Jim Runnels and seven of his band were executed' (Two Thousand Miles on Horseback, 1867, S-0329, p. 77); Alice Polk Hill has them 'blindfolded and deliberately shot down under orders' 'near the head of Cherry creek, in Douglass county' (Tales of the Colorado Pioneers, 1884, S-0333, p. 171); and A. K. Shaw, who said he commanded the firing party, put it on the march 'down the Squirrel Creek road,' behind 'a little bluff' (Luella Shaw, True History, 1909, S-0334, p. 44). Marr follows the Engl-Winkler tradition, with five prisoners, and adds Uncle Dick Wootton's report that he saw five men manacled to trees and shot (Marr, S-0185, p. 61).

Where it was

Placed just east of the Russellville marker, where the 1864 report puts the shooting and where Cook's five-mile march began; Cook gives no direction for the march. The 1958 local tradition puts the spot on the old Engl ranch in the Lake Gulch and Castlewood area, but its two descriptions disagree ('five miles from the site of early day Russellville'; 'between one and two miles east' of the Winkler ranch, which is 3.4 miles from this point), so no second point is mapped. Good to several miles.

Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.

See it on the map

Sources

  • S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
  • S-0058: Frank Hall, History of the State of Colorado, vol. 3 (1891) and vol. 4 (1895)
  • S-0093: Russellville in the newspapers, 1860–1898 (via S-0016)
  • S-0185: Josephine Lowell Marr, Douglas County: A Historical Journey (1983)
  • S-0186: The Reynolds gang in the Colorado newspapers, 1864–1959 (CHNC)
  • S-0187: David J. Cook, Hands Up; or, Thirty-Five Years of Detective Life in the Mountains and on the Plains (Denver, 1897; first ed. 1882)
  • S-0188: Alejandro Hernández, "The Reynolds Gang: Colorado Confederates and Their Buried Treasure," Denver Public Library Special Collections and Archives blog, April 14, 2020
  • S-0329: James F. Meline, Two Thousand Miles on Horseback: Santa Fé and Back. A Summer Tour through Kansas, Nebraska, Colorado, and New Mexico, in the Year 1866 (New York: Hurd and Houghton, 1867)
  • S-0333: Alice Polk Hill, Tales of the Colorado Pioneers (Denver: Pierson & Gardner, 1884)
  • S-0334: Luella Shaw, True History of Some of the Pioneers of Colorado (Hotchkiss, Colo., 1909)

Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.

Know more about Reynolds gang shot (Sept. 1864)?

Corrections, family stories, photographs, deeds, letters and maps are all welcome. Messages and files come to Michael Christensen privately; nothing appears on the site until it has been checked, and you'll be credited the way you ask.