What we know
Two men killed in the September 1868 raids. A dispatch from Ayres, superintendent of the Denver & Santa Fe stage line, said 'two men were killed at Buzzard's station' the day before (Rocky Mountain News, Sept. 5, 1868, S-0092). The Gazette's writer of 1878 was shown 'the exact spot where ten years ago, the 4th of this month, two men, Jos. Talbot and Ed. Davis, were killed by the redskins' (Sept. 21, 1878, volunteer-corrected CHNC text, S-0146, S-0306). Amanda Talbert Husted, Calvin Husted's wife, named them as her brother Joseph Talbert and Edward Davis, said neither had a gun and that each was shot several times and neither was scalped (Sunday Gazette and Telegraph, March 23, 1930, via Wismer, S-0305, p. 60). Howbert (1914, S-0028) has 'a Mr. Davis and Job Talbert, a brother-in-law of Mr. Husted,' killed and scalped on the road back to Husted's mill, about three miles from the ranch they had left; Mathews puts it 'in the Pinery near Husted's mill' (Early Days Around the Divide, 1969, S-0020, p. 14); Walter Husted (1949) remembered 1864 and 'a man named Young.' Two papers of the time and the sister agree on Joseph Talbert and Edward Davis and Sept. 4, 1868; Howbert's Job and Walter's date and name are the outliers, and the scalping is her word against Howbert's. The two were buried in one grave, place not given.
People
- Calvin R. Husted (1832–1908): his brother-in-law killed here, 1868
Where it was
The News put the killing 'at Buzzard's station' (Sept. 5, 1868, S-0092); drawn just southeast of that pin so both show. The 1878 writer was shown 'the exact spot' on a ride of some ten miles from Husted's house, without a direction (S-0146), and Walter Husted had the men killed walking back from the Buzzard ranch to the sawmill (via Wismer, S-0305, p. 60). Good to about half a mile.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0020: Carl F. Mathews and E.C. Matthews, Early Days Around the Divide (St. Louis: Sign Book Co., [1969]), 78 p., illus., map, ports.
- S-0028: Irving Howbert, The Indians of the Pike's Peak Region: Including an Account of the Battle of Sand Creek, and of Occurrences in El Paso County, Colorado, during the War with the Cheyennes and Arapahoes, in 1864 and 1868 (The Knickerbocker Press, New York, 1914)
- S-0092: The September 1868 raids in the newspapers (via S-0016)
- S-0146: Husted in the Colorado newspapers, 1870–1956: headline sweep (CHNC)
- S-0305: David A. Wismer with Gary T. Wright, Shamrock Ranch: Celebrating Life in Colorado's Pikes Peak Country (Boulder: Johnson Books, 2009), 298 pp. and index
- S-0306: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection: two checks for Wismer's Shamrock Ranch (S-0305), 2026-10-23
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.