What we know
David Rice Williams's ranch, cheese factory, creamery and store on West Cherry Creek ('Williamsville' in the newspapers from 1895). Williams came in 1872 or 1873 and first homesteaded on Antelope Creek, in a settlement of Tennessee families; when most of them went home he bought this place on Cherry Creek from a family anxious to leave (Crosswhite family story; Ruth L. Miller, 1996; both S-0199). Charles E. Crosswhite managed the Williams creamery and cheese factory from 1897 and brought in the Babcock butterfat test; in 1913 the Crosswhites took the Williams 'home place', 760 acres with the buildings of the former store and cheese factory, and his Cherry Creek Mercantile & Transportation Company ran motor trucks between Cherry and Denver (S-0199). Cherry PO opened spring 1900, 'locally known as Williamsville'; closed 1920. By Bauer's register Elvira O. Williams was the first postmaster (April 7, 1900), David D. Gray (March 29, 1911) and Ida R. Lambert (March 24, 1919) followed, and the office closed Aug. 31, 1920, mail to Castle Rock (Bauer 2003, S-0391, p. 4; S-0392, p. 25). Williamsville was refused as a name, and so, Bauer says, was Lawton (p. 25); the application offered Lawton, Clover, Cherry and Snow (S-0113). The Grays kept the store and post office in 1916, when Lucy Lambert ran both in their absence (Record Journal, Jan. 7, 1916, S-0199); she was a stand-in, not an appointee (our reading). D. R. Williams (d. 1912) and Elvira O. Williams (1841-1906) are buried at Spring Valley (S-0199). David R. Williams's land patents: in T9S R66W, the E1/2 SE of Sec. 34 (Nov. 15, 1873), the NW SW of Sec. 26 (Oct. 1, 1880) and land in the west half of Sec. 35 (June 30, 1881); in Sec. 6, T10S R65W, around this point, the SE NW (Dec. 10, 1881) and the E1/2 SW with the north part of Sec. 7's NW quarter (June 30, 1884); and two lots on the township lines in 1901 (BLM GLO, S-0080). Place Names of Colorado's Sec. 6 is his. A cabinet card titled 'A Cheese Ranche near Greenland, Colorado', from a negative by J. E. Hayes dated 1892, shows wooden buildings, corrals and wagons; the library's cataloguer identifies it as the Williams cheese factory (Douglas County Libraries photos/3497, S-0213). Weber and Schlupp have D. R. Williams homesteading on Antelope Creek in 1873 and moving in 1881 to a new ranch on West Cherry Creek north of Spring Valley, which grew to 1,180 acres; he built a new cheese factory in 1890 with a New York cheesemaker and closed it in 1905 (ch. 21, O'Pry, pp. 113-114; S-0262). The 1873 date is his first homestead, not this place. In the storm that broke Castlewood Dam on the night of Aug. 2-3, 1933, residents' improvised gauges caught 7 inches in Secs. 1 and 2, T10S R66W, around Cherry, and 9 inches, measured in a 10-gallon milk can, in Sec. 4, about three miles west (Follansbee and Sawyer, USGS Water-Supply Paper 997, 1948, p. 66, S-0264). Margaret Long's trails map, which Marr reproduces, draws an unnamed station on West Cherry Creek between Spring Valley and Virginia Ranch at the T9S/T10S line, about where this point is (Marr, S-0185, pp. 24, 47). Marr: David Rice Williams held '1180 acres of deeded land' and leased a section of school land, and named the area Williamsville 'after his home town in Massachusetts' (Marr, S-0185, p. 54); the post office 'objected to such a long name,' so the petitioners chose Cherry (p. 55), which is why no Williamsville office is in the lists. His cheese factory brought him to the forefront in 1888, and when it closed in 1905 it was the state's oldest-operating cheese factory; milk came from a ten-mile radius (Elbert, Elizabeth, Lake Gulch, Golddale, East Cherry Creek and Spring Valley), and a Babcock tester caught a farmer watering his milk (p. 54). A Williams girl's ride of 'three and one half miles' to the Whittiers' (p. 56) fits the two pins, 2.9 straight miles apart.
People
- David R. Williams (1837–1912): his ranch, cheese factory and store from 1881; Williamsville named for him
Where it was
NW1/4 of Sec. 6, T10S R65W, from Elvira O. Williams's post office site report of Feb. 23, 1900: 'Case is 4 miles northerly; 10 rods north of West Cherry Creek' (Bauer 2003, S-0391, p. 4; S-0392, p. 25). The quarter is made of government lots, so the point is the center of the lots' centroids on the BLM PLSS grid; good to about a quarter mile. The quarter holds David R. Williams's own SE NW forty, patented in 1881 (BLM GLO, S-0080), and fits Bauer's 2003 directions: 4 1/4 miles south on Highway 83 from Russellville Road, then a private road west into an old ranch complex west of the creek (S-0392, p. 25). Formerly placed 0.36 mile southwest (good to about half a mile), on the later Anderson ranch, 10425 S. Hwy 83, by interpolating addresses along Hwy 83, with 'The Pratt schoolhouse, a mile south of Williamsville' (1899) and the Cherry School lot at the NE corner of Sec. 12, T10S R66W (deeds); Place Names of Colorado's Sec. 6 is the report's section.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0044: Books to borrow on the Internet Archive (controlled lending, in copyright)
- S-0046: Douglas County Libraries, Archives & Local History: "Douglas County Timeline," "Douglas County Historic Sites," "Douglas County Schools Overview" (research collection PDFs 2, 7, 6)
- S-0064: Wikipedia, "List of post offices in Colorado" (A–F, G–O, P–Z) and town articles
- S-0065: Colorado Council of Genealogical Societies, Place Names of Colorado (1999), PDF hosted by the Denver Public Library
- S-0066: Jim Forte Postal History, U.S. post office database (postalhistory.com)
- S-0080: General Land Office land patents, Bureau of Land Management (glorecords.blm.gov)
- S-0084: Cherry and Williamsville in the newspapers, 1883–1906 (via S-0016)
- S-0113: U.S. Post Office Department, Reports of Site Locations, 1837–1950 (NARA microfilm M1126), Colorado rolls 73 and 74: Douglas, Elbert and El Paso counties
- S-0120: Bureau of Land Management, National Public Land Survey System (PLSS) data: CadNSDI section and quarter-section polygons, Colorado
- S-0185: Josephine Lowell Marr, Douglas County: A Historical Journey (1983)
- S-0199: Larkspur Historical Society, the document store behind its "LHS Search Agent" (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org/resources/lhs-search-agents/): 362 files, about 810 MB, uploaded April–June 2026
- S-0213: Douglas County Libraries, Archives & Local History, digital archive (archives.dcl.org, CONTENTdm cdm17197): item records of all 15 collections
- S-0262: Tim Weber and Larry Schlupp, eds., Douglas County, Colorado: Prehistory to 2020 (Castle Rock: Historic Douglas County, Inc., 2022; first edition, printed by Amazon)
- S-0264: Robert Follansbee and Leon R. Sawyer, Floods in Colorado, U.S. Geological Survey Water-Supply Paper 997 (1948)
- S-0391: William O. Bauer, Post Offices of Douglas County, Colorado (Unadilla, N.Y.: the author, 2003), typescript, 19 pp.
- S-0392: William H. Bauer, "Colorado Postal Encyclopedia: Douglas County," Colorado Postal Historian 19, nos. 1 and 2 (2003; no. 2 is December 2003, whole no. 72), pp. 9–80 (journal of the Colorado Postal Historical Society, ISSN 0887-1663)
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.