What we know
'P.O.' in a one-story frame building on this lot in July 1890, Nov. 1902 and July 1907. In Sept. 1895 the post office was across Wilcox, sharing a frame building with a drugstore on the corner where the Keystone Hotel stood by 1902; in Sept. 1914 it was at the southeast corner of Wilcox and Fourth, about 75 feet north of this point. The 1914 map places the high school 'Located 2½ Blocks North of P.O.' (S-0190). Appleby's Fading Past (2001) has the post office moving to Wilcox Street in 1899, when 'a solid front of business houses from third street to fourth street' stood there (West Creek Mining News, May 20, 1899, via p. 11, S-0303); the Sanborn maps already show it on Wilcox in 1890 and 1895, so the 1899 move was probably back across the street to this lot. From the move from New Memphis on May 18, 1874, Castle Rock's postmasters included Charles Grimes Jr., the first; Simeon W. Cantril (1876); John C. Sellars (1880); Mrs. Phila Webster (1883-86, 1889-93 and 1899-1910); Frank B. Ross (April 19, 1887), who came from the Larkspur office; Alfred E. or F. Stott (Oct. 6, 1893; 'Scott, Alfred F.' in Bauer); Rufus P. Conant (Nov. 20, 1897); and Ellen E. Potter (1910), under whom the office became presidential on Jan. 1, 1912 (Bauer 2003, S-0391, p. 3; S-0392, pp. 19-20). Grimes's site report of May 16, 1874 puts the first office in the NW1/4 of Sec. 11, '80 rods east of East Plum Creek,' on the east side of the D&RG by Bauer's reading (S-0392, p. 19), where our reading of the form has the west side (NARA 073-0600, S-0113); the form needs a second look. From 1920 the office was on Third Street (mapped). The town's survey of 316 Wilcox St. has a drugstore and the post office in the Webster family's building there in 1887; Phila Webster's family owned it from 1885 to 1932 (5DA.2676, 2012, S-0418; mapped as Webster Buildings, 20 feet from this pin).
People
- Alfred F. Stott (born 1868): postmaster, 1893-97; the office was in his drugstore for a time
- Amos G. Webster (1841–1926): his wife was postmaster; the office was in their building in 1887
Where it was
East side of Wilcox Street between Third and Fourth, the third lot from Fourth (block 19, lot 23), on the Sanborn Fire Insurance Map of Castle Rock, sheet 2, July 1890 (Library of Congress, S-0190); placed by fitting the sheet to today's Wilcox and Perry street crossings at 2nd to 5th streets (eight points, each within about 10 feet of the fit). Good to about a hundred feet.
Sources
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0044: Books to borrow on the Internet Archive (controlled lending, in copyright)
- S-0113: U.S. Post Office Department, Reports of Site Locations, 1837–1950 (NARA microfilm M1126), Colorado rolls 73 and 74: Douglas, Elbert and El Paso counties
- S-0190: Sanborn-Perris Map Co. and Sanborn Map Co., Castle Rock, Douglas County, Colorado, fire-insurance maps, two sheets each: July 1890, September 1895, November 1902, July 1907 and September 1914 (Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division, Sanborn Maps collection)
- S-0303: Susan Consola Appleby, Fading Past: The Story of Douglas County, Colorado (Palmer Lake: Filter Press, 2001; ISBN 0-86541-060-7), x + 210 pp.
- S-0391: William O. Bauer, Post Offices of Douglas County, Colorado (Unadilla, N.Y.: the author, 2003), typescript, 19 pp.
- S-0392: William H. Bauer, "Colorado Postal Encyclopedia: Douglas County," Colorado Postal Historian 19, nos. 1 and 2 (2003; no. 2 is December 2003, whole no. 72), pp. 9–80 (journal of the Colorado Postal Historical Society, ISSN 0887-1663)
- S-0418: Town of Castle Rock, Survey of Historic Resources: Colorado Cultural Resource Survey architectural inventory forms, 2007-2016 (recorder Barbara Darden, Scheuber + Darden Architects), Town of Castle Rock Historic Building Site Files, Douglas County Libraries
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.