Palmer Divide Research Project

Cantril Courthouse (1874)

Cantril Courthouse (1874) is a historic or vanished place in Douglas County, Colorado, on the Palmer Divide, listed here under other historic buildings.

Also: County offices and lodge room (Wilcox and Fourth) · 'County Off's' (1890) · Castle Rock Journal building · bank and lodge room (1902) · post office (1914)

Other historic buildingsHistoric or vanishedDouglas County

What we know

A two-story frame building marked 'County Off's' on the July 1890 Sanborn map, across Wilcox from the courthouse square. Later uses of the same corner lot: a printing office with a lodge room on the second floor, a barber and a doctor's office (1895); a bank with the lodge room upstairs (1902); a bank and a clothing, boot and shoe store (1907); and the post office, a cobbler and a jeweler (1914). The maps do not name the lodge (S-0190). This is William Cantril's courthouse of 1874. The county commissioners' articles of agreement of April 28, 1874 had Cantril build a two-story frame building, 20 by 40 feet, on lot 18 in block 19 of Castle Rock by June 15, for $1,350 in all, and it served as the county courthouse until the stone courthouse was finished in 1890 (commissioners' minutes, as transcribed in the town's 2010 survey form, S-0293; Weber and Schlupp, ch. 13, p. 70, S-0262). The county sold it in 1901, and it later housed the Castle Rock Journal (DCL photograph 1992.001.0678.0003, S-0213). In October 1920 the Castle Rock Mercantile moved it about 100 feet east along Fourth Street to make room for its brick store on the corner, and in 2010 it still stood at 308-312 Fourth St., with later additions on both sides (S-0293); the survey's map reference falls 94 feet east of this pin, which marks the original site. The tradition that Cantril built it elsewhere and moved it is old. His obituary in the Castle Rock Journal of Feb. 20, 1903, the earliest telling found, says that when many favored his Cherry Creek ranch for the county seat he put up a courthouse of lumber from his own sawmill and gave it to the county, and that when Castle Rock was chosen the building was taken down and moved there (CHNC, S-0301). Elizabeth Tallman's memoir has it built near his sawmill and moved by way of Franktown (Colorado Magazine, July 1946, p. 185, S-0072), and Lowenberg's Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (1980) (p. 145, S-0300), Bull's 1994 history of Frankstown (n. 26-27, S-0298) and Appleby's 1995 thesis (S-0291, p. 44) repeat it; her Fading Past (2001) drops the story and follows the contract, from Kent Brandebery's draft quoting the minutes, pp. 256 and 264 (pp. 18-19, S-0303). The contract of April 28, 1874 is for a building on this lot; both can be true if the $1,350 paid for taking down, re-erecting and finishing a frame building Cantril already had (inference). Lowenberg's $350 contract, from a minute-book page that looks misread, is the outlier. A cigar butt set the building on fire on Feb. 15, 1888, which started the push for a stone courthouse, and the county offered it for rent in June 1890 (Castle Rock Journal and the commissioners' minutes, via Lowenberg, pp. 145, 150). The Douglas County Bank opened in 1901 'in the old courthouse building on Wilcox and Fourth streets' and later moved a block south to a rhyolite building (Fading Past, p. 12), which fits the 1903 obituary's bank. Appleby gives the address as 315 Fourth St. (p. 18), against the 2010 survey's 308-312. Marr gives the fullest telling of the moved-building tradition, without naming Cantril: the building came from the California Ranch at Frankstown on wooden runners, over the hills to a point a mile north of town and then south; the county safe was moved on May 4, 1874; the building was set at Fourth and Wilcox 'opposite the square' and was ready 'about the 15th of June or before'; and it was moved a short way east in 1920 (Marr, S-0185, pp. 142, 164-165). Her dates go beside the contract of April 28, 1874 as the tradition's; his first site near Franktown is in the unlocated list. Marr in 1974: it 'stood facing west on the corner where there is a Barber Shop today' at 324 Wilcox, and the building stood 'so humbly there on the alley' (Douglas County News, Dec. 19, 1974, S-0438); in 1971 she called it the 'old Kobolt Press building at 308-4th Street' (April 15, 1971).

People

  • John Pollock (1848–1927): painted 'the courthouse at Castle Rock,' 1874 (probably this building)
  • Elizabeth Tallman (1841–1941): her memoir's account of its move by way of Franktown

Where it was

Southeast corner of Wilcox and Fourth (block 19, lots 24-25), on the Sanborn Fire Insurance Map of Castle Rock, sheet 2, July 1890 (Library of Congress, S-0190); placed by fitting the sheet to today's Wilcox and Perry street crossings at 2nd to 5th streets (eight points, each within about 10 feet of the fit). Good to about a hundred feet.

See it on the map

Sources

  • S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
  • S-0046: Douglas County Libraries, Archives & Local History: "Douglas County Timeline," "Douglas County Historic Sites," "Douglas County Schools Overview" (research collection PDFs 2, 7, 6)
  • S-0072: The Colorado Magazine (State Historical Society of Colorado), 30 issues 1931–1977, full text
  • S-0185: Josephine Lowell Marr, Douglas County: A Historical Journey (1983)
  • S-0190: Sanborn-Perris Map Co. and Sanborn Map Co., Castle Rock, Douglas County, Colorado, fire-insurance maps, two sheets each: July 1890, September 1895, November 1902, July 1907 and September 1914 (Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division, Sanborn Maps collection)
  • S-0213: Douglas County Libraries, Archives & Local History, digital archive (archives.dcl.org, CONTENTdm cdm17197): item records of all 15 collections
  • S-0262: Tim Weber and Larry Schlupp, eds., Douglas County, Colorado: Prehistory to 2020 (Castle Rock: Historic Douglas County, Inc., 2022; first edition, printed by Amazon)
  • S-0291: Susan K. Appleby, "Douglas County: History and Guide to Cultural Resources" (M.A. thesis, History, University of Colorado at Denver, 1995; directed by Thomas J. Noel), x + 337 PDF pp.
  • S-0293: Barbara Darden (Scheuber + Darden Architects), Colorado Cultural Resource Survey, Architectural Inventory Form, Cantril Courthouse (5DA2722), 308-312 Fourth Street, Castle Rock (April 2010; photographs September 2010), for the Town of Castle Rock's survey of historic resources
  • S-0298: James C. Bull, A Short History of Frankstown, Colorado: A Douglas County Cross Roads ([Franktown]: the author, first printing December 1994; printed by Kwik Kopy Printing), 27 pp. of text, unpaginated
  • S-0300: Robert Lowenberg and his "What is History?" classes at Douglas County High School, Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (Castle Rock, Colo.: Robert L. Lowenberg, first printing 1980), 175 pp.
  • S-0301: Castle Rock Journal (Castle Rock, Colo.), Feb. 20, 1903: obituary of William W. Cantril, via the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection
  • S-0303: Susan Consola Appleby, Fading Past: The Story of Douglas County, Colorado (Palmer Lake: Filter Press, 2001; ISBN 0-86541-060-7), x + 210 pp.
  • S-0438: Josephine Lowell Marr ("Mrs. John Marr"), local-history columns in The Douglas County News (Castle Rock), 1967–1976: "Douglas County History," "If Walls Could Speak" and "Walk With Our Pioneers," with the old newspaper items she reprinted (CHNC)

Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.

Photographs and records at Douglas County Libraries

Held by the library's Archives and Local History in Castle Rock. The links open the library's records. The Town of Castle Rock's survey forms are architectural inventories of the building, with photographs.

From the Town of Castle Rock Historic Building Site Files:

Know more about Cantril Courthouse (1874)?

Corrections, family stories, photographs, deeds, letters and maps are all welcome. Messages and files come to Michael Christensen privately; nothing appears on the site until it has been checked, and you'll be credited the way you ask.