What we know
Peterson, a tie contractor on the creek since the Kansas Pacific was built and a feared 'hard case', was shot six times in his house on Saturday afternoon, April 27, 1872, by Evan E. Hall, a gambler who held a bill of sale for his property. Hall claimed self-defense; Justice Killin at Kiowa released him on May 6 on William Wilder's testimony, but the Douglas County grand jury indicted him on June 5 (News, May-June 1872). Peterson's brother Ephraim was shot dead by Tom Quinlan, a Gomer's Mill logger, in a quarrel over strayed mules in June 1874 (News, June 19, 1874). Hall killed J. H. Hooker at Gomer's mill in March 1875 and was himself shot dead in an ambush on West Cherry Creek on Aug. 6-7, 1875.
People
- Evan E. Hall (died 1875): shot Andrew Peterson here, 1872, and filed a homestead entry on it
- Bernard Chester Killin (1845–1911): heard the Hall case as justice at Kiowa, May 1872
- Andrew Peterson (died 1872): his ranch, where he was killed, 1872
Where it was
S1/2 of Sec. 9, T10S R64W (E1/2 SW and W1/2 SE): Evan E. Hall's homestead entry No. 2355 of May 17, 1872, three weeks after the killing, which August Peterson contested for the heirs of Andrew Peterson, claiming a prior right (land-office notice, News, Jan. 1873); center of those four forties via the BLM PLSS survey grid. That the entry was Peterson's ranch is an inference from the contest. Good to about half a mile. The News put the killing 'on West Kiowa creek, three miles west from Gomer's mill, on the rancho of Andrew Peterson' (May 3, 1872); this point is 2.5 miles west-northwest of the mapped Gomer's Mill.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0116: CHNC newspapers: the Hall–Peterson killings and the Hall–Wilder gang on the Divide, 1871–75
- S-0120: Bureau of Land Management, National Public Land Survey System (PLSS) data: CadNSDI section and quarter-section polygons, Colorado
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.