Biography
Von Ahlefeldt calls Evan Hall the leader of a local group of roughnecks who shot Andrew Peterson near Gomer's Mill in 1872 (von Ahlefeldt, S-0009, p. 73). The Rocky Mountain News describes Evan E. Hall as a gambler who held a bill of sale for Peterson's property and was staying at his ranch on West Kiowa Creek when he shot him on April 27, 1872; Hall claimed self-defense and was released at Kiowa on May 6, but the Douglas County grand jury indicted him for murder on June 5 (News, May 3, May 12 and June 7, 1872, S-0116). Mathews says he was exonerated (Mathews, S-0020, p. 16). Three weeks after the killing he filed a homestead entry on the land, which Peterson's heirs contested (as given in the place note, S-0116).
In 1875 the News described Hall and William N. Wilder as young and unmarried men who had lived on the Divide several years and worked at Gomer's mill, sixty miles from Denver; about a year earlier Hall had opened a whisky and gambling place, where losers were made to sign orders on P. P. Gomer totaling over $3,000, and when Gomer refused them Hall and Wilder threatened his life (News, March 26, 1875, S-0116; Mathews, who calls Wilder Hall's brother-in-law, S-0020, p. 16). On March 24, 1875, when officers came to the mill to arrest them, Hall shot and killed J. H. Hooker, the deputy's father; wounded, he gave himself up at Colorado Springs on March 29 and was taken to the Denver jail (S-0020, p. 16; News, March 30, 1875, S-0116).
Late in July 1875 Hall, Wilder and Henry (Harry) Leighton broke out of the jail, Hall leaving behind a letter to the News, dated July 26, that blamed his troubles on enemies headed by Gomer (News, Aug. 1, 1875, S-0116). A posse surprised the three on the night of Friday, Aug. 6, on the Divide, killing Hall and Leighton, whose bodies were brought to Denver (News, Aug. 8, 1875, S-0116); the posse had decoyed them to a corral near Blakesley's mill on West Cherry Creek (News, Aug. 8, 1875, S-0116). Mathews says a relative near Spring Valley betrayed him (S-0020, p. 17).
The 1898 sketch of Samuel L. Griffin of Elbert says he married 'Mrs. Mary Hall, nee Gray, of Douglas County' on July 9, 1879 (Portrait and Biographical Record, 1898, S-0191, p. 1112), and Mathews writes that Mrs. Griffin had been the young widow of Evan Hall (Mathews, S-0020, p. 50); her maiden name agrees with the News's naming of a James Gray as Hall's brother-in-law, against the News's description of Hall as unmarried.
Places
- Andrew Peterson killed (April 27, 1872): shot Andrew Peterson here, 1872, and filed a homestead entry on it
- Gomer's Mill: worked at the mill and ran a saloon near it; killed J. H. Hooker there, 1875
Sources
- S-0009: Judy von Ahlefeldt, Thunder, Sun and Snow: The History of Colorado's Black Forest (Colorado Springs: Century One Press, a division of Graphic Services, Inc., 1979)
- S-0116: CHNC newspapers: the Hall–Peterson killings and the Hall–Wilder gang on the Divide, 1871–75 (online)
- S-0020: Carl F. Mathews and E.C. Matthews, Early Days Around the Divide (St. Louis: Sign Book Co., [1969]), 78 p., illus., map, ports.
- S-0191: Portrait and Biographical Record of Denver and Vicinity, Colorado (Chicago: Chapman Publishing Company, 1898) (online)
Every fact above names its source; numbers such as S-0246 refer to our source list. Find a Grave memorials are compiled by volunteers and are matched here only where their dates or family agree with the sources we have read.