What we know
Mountain above Palmer Lake, earlier 'Ben Floss Mountain' (PLHS, 'Lucretia Vaile,' S-0002). Volunteers (Gilbert Wolf, Floyd Bellinger, George Sill, Jesse Krueger and his sons) built the star on its face, first lit in mid-December 1935 (OCN write-ups of PLHS talks, S-0112). It is on the Colorado State Register of Historic Properties (5EP.7092, listed Jan. 24, 2013), on a nomination Jack Anthony wrote for the historical society (S-0348). The deed by which Arthur and Reba Bradley gave the site to the town is dated Jan. 24, 1966, so the listing came 47 years to the day after it. Tim Wagner, whose 2009 survey measured the star for the nomination, died on Jan. 20, 2013, two days after the state review board's unanimous vote (Jack Anthony's 2013 pamphlet, S-0350). B. E. Jack, regional manager of Mountain Utilities, proposed the star at Bert Sloan's café in June 1935; Arthur Bradley, who owned the slope, agreed, and he and Reba Bradley deeded the site to the town in 1966. Byron Medlock, a surveyor, designed it; Mountain Utilities gave used poles and cable, and the town council $140. Volunteers carried the materials up by bucket brigade, helped by Sloan's German shepherd, Dizzy, who wore a pack; Dizzy now has a statue on the Village Green (S-0351). The first 100-watt bulbs made a fuzzy glow and gave way to 25-watt ones, and the bulbs were moved on the directions of watchers around town until the points looked even. The volunteer fire department has kept the star since 1937. Jesse Krueger's sons Harry, Orville and Kenny replaced burned-out bulbs each December into the early 1950s. In Harry's telling, one December morning in 1948 the boys found a mountain lion lying in the sun by a dead bulb and ran home; their father sent them back up, saying 'the lion will be gone,' and it was (Harry Krueger's account to Jack Anthony, S-0352). Harry, retired from the Army and living at the foot of the mountain, led the 1976 bicentennial rebuild, when a helicopter flew in steel posts to replace the wooden ones; the airlift took three hours, against three months for the first building. Todd Bell of the fire department led the 2002 rewiring; by then the star used special five-filament bulbs, to stand up to high winds and to the antlers of deer that cross under the star (S-0348). A 2009 survey makes the star 457.3 feet across and 404.8 feet tall, its top point 251.6 feet above its lower-left point on a 58 percent slope; the nomination counts 91 bulbs on 30 posts, on a 1.5-acre site within the town's 14 acres. Jack Anthony's later summary says the star was built with 91 and that the 2002 crew added a 92nd, and that in 2014 Palmer Lake Elementary School's Green Panther Club raised the money to replace the bulbs with LEDs (S-0351). The nomination names one other lit star of comparable size laid flat on a hillside, in El Paso, Texas (S-0348). PLHS gives the star's site as 14 acres 'just West of the Town' on a 58 percent slope, facing a bearing of 111 degrees, and names Rod VanVelson and Jane VanVelson-Potts's 'Star Light, Star Bright' (1980) as its history (S-0002). The point is the star's top point; the summit is about a third of a mile west-southwest. Countess Murat's cottage stood 'below Sundance Mountain.' A fringe place. Hermina Kilgore's 1961 memoir also has the star 'constructed in 1935 by men of the village' (Rough Road in the Rockies, p. 90, S-0302).
Where it was
The star's top point, 39°07'24.67" N, 104°55'23.72" W, from Wagner Land Surveying's survey of Jan. 30, 2009 in the State Register nomination (S-0348); the nomination's UTM reference agrees within about 125 feet. The star runs about 400 feet down the slope to the east-southeast of this point. The Sundance Mountain summit (USGS GNIS, 2021 Colorado file, S-0007) is about a third of a mile west-southwest. Good to a few feet.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0002: Palmer Lake Historical Society website (palmerdividehistory.org)
- S-0006: USGS Geographic Names Information System, Colorado file, 2021-08-25 edition
- S-0007: USGS GNIS DomesticNames, Colorado (current edition)
- S-0112: Our Community News (ocn.me), Monument: items on the Chamber's meeting house (the Gwillimville schoolhouse)
- S-0302: Hermina Gertrude Kilgore, Rough Road in the Rockies (Denver: Big Mountain Press, 1961), 135 pp. and 4 plates
- S-0348: Jack Anthony, "Palmer Lake Star," Colorado State Register of Historic Properties nomination (5EP.7092), Oct. 5, 2012; listed Jan. 24, 2013
- S-0350: Jack Anthony, The Palmer Lake Star: Colorado State Register of Historic Properties (Palmer Lake Historical Society, November 2013), four-page pamphlet; edition of Feb. 5, 2014
- S-0351: Jack Anthony, "11 Cool Things to Know about the Palmer Lake Star" (October 2023), one slide
- S-0352: Jack Anthony, "Krueger Boys Meet the Guardian of the Palmer Lake Star" (three slides, 2025 or later)
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.