What we know
Where St. Mary's parish built its first church in 1905, on ground consecrated by Archbishop (later Patriarch and Saint) Tikhon, beside its cemeteries S-0224. The library's cataloger says Matt and Mary Trojanovich gave two acres for an Orthodox church and cemetery about 1905, and that the church was 'rebuilt in 1931 following a fire' (PPLD records of 1976 survey photos A36, S-0101); the newspapers date the fire that destroyed the brick church to Jan. 23, 1928 (S-0211). In the 1970s a photographer took 'St. Michael Cemetery' with its arched iron gate, looking toward the church (S-0218). The site was rededicated as St. Tikhon's Chapel in 1995; the chapel burned in June 2000 ('Historic Calhan chapel burns,' Gazette, June 11, 2000, S-0218) and was restored by 2013 S-0224. King's history: priests from Denver said mass in the Hlatki School in 1903-05, and Matt and Mary Trojanovich gave two acres (King, S-0390, pp. 69, 225). The brick church, with a tall shingled spire, was 'five and a half miles north,' finished by July 4 and consecrated on Aug. 28, 1905; Father Ina Kibikoff was the first permanent priest (p. 69). Andrew Trojanovich was a carpenter on it, Joseph Roskos did the woodwork and Franz Hartung painted the interior scenes (pp. 170, 210, 224). A church hall went up about 1912 on Hlatki land (p. 69). After the fire (1927 by the parish; the papers' Jan. 23, 1928 stands), the church was rebuilt smaller on the same site and dedicated in 1932 as 'the Church on the Hill,' little used and a historical monument in 1980 (p. 69). So the single-spired church in Conarroe's photograph is the rebuild of 1932 on the hill, the building rededicated as St. Tikhon's Chapel in 1995, and the library's 'rebuilt in 1931' is the same rebuild. Matt Trojanovich's homestead (1897-98) lay 'between the Church on the Hill and St. Marys on the corner' (p. 225). The distance is given as 5½ miles (p. 69), 'five' (a caption) or 'six' (p. 224); this pin is 5.7 miles from Calhan. Which cemetery is which is not settled. King puts St. Mary's cemetery 'on the east side of Calhan Highway, just north of the Church on the Hill' (p. 69), and St. Michael's, given by Mike Hlatki when Mary Hlatki died in 1935, 'directly west of the Church on the Hill' (pp. 71, 174). The county's records, as King quotes them, have St. Michael's 'established in 1905' and 'on both sides of the road, 5½ miles north' (p. 77). GNIS puts Saint Michaels Cemetery east of the road, at this point, and Saint Mary's 200 feet west. If King is right, GNIS has the names swapped, and the 1905 church stood east of the road just south of the eastern plot; aerial imagery or the parish should settle it.
Where it was
USGS GNIS 'Saint Michaels Cemetery' (193302, S-0006), east of the Calhan Highway; GNIS 'Saint Mary's Cemetery' (1834817) is 200 feet west, across the road (OpenStreetMap polygons for both, S-0103). The 1976 survey puts its church and cemetery 'on the east side of Calhan Highway, 5 miles north of Calhan' (S-0101); the parish puts the 1932 church 'about half a mile south of the original site' S-0224; these cemeteries are 0.37 mile north of it (our reading). The chapel's own footprint is not identified. Good to about 300 feet.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0006: USGS Geographic Names Information System, Colorado file, 2021-08-25 edition
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0017: Pikes Peak Library District, Regional History & Genealogy
- S-0101: Elaine Freed and David Barber, Historic Sites & Structures, El Paso County, Colorado ([Colorado Springs]: prepared for the El Paso County Land Use Department, [1977]), 56 pp., with the survey photographs in PPLD's Historic Sites and Structures collection
- S-0103: OpenStreetMap extracts via the Overpass API (2026-10-05)
- S-0108: The Gazette and The Tribune (Pikes Peak Newspapers) on gazette.com: local-history columns and features
- S-0211: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection: the Russian Orthodox Greek Catholic church at Calhan, 1905-1936 (via S-0016)
- S-0218: Pikes Peak Library District, Digital Collections (digitalcollections.ppld.org): sweep of 2026-10-14 (Pikes Peak NewsFinder index records; photograph, map and oral-history records)
- S-0224: St. Mary's Holy Dormition Orthodox Church, Calhan: parish website (holydormition.net), "Our Parish & History," "St. Tikhon's Chapel" and "Cemeteries" pages
- S-0249: Percy Conarroe, Calhan: Life in a Small Town on the Plains of Eastern Colorado (Lafayette, Colo.: 6000 Bees LLC, 2005; 2nd printing or edition 2017)
- S-0390: Larry L. King, The History of Calhan and Vicinity, 1888–1988 (Simla, Colo.: Gaddy Printing Company, 1987), ISBN 0-9619442-0-X; LCCN 87-32719
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.
1976 survey photographs
Taken for Elaine Freed and David Barber's survey of El Paso County's historic sites and held by the Pikes Peak Library District. The links open the library's records.