What we know
The cornerstone of the original one-and-a-half-story house is dated 1875; additions followed in 1893, 1901 and 1932, and a barn of about 1890 (replacing one that burned that year), a chicken coop and a rhyolite ice house of about 1875 still stand behind it. Samuel M. Dyer, son of the Methodist preacher Father John L. Dyer, bought the lots from Jeremiah Gould in October 1874 and is believed to have built the house in 1875, after he became county clerk and recorder in 1874 and found the ride in from his ranch too hard; he married Esther Alexander in 1881, moved to Pueblo and then Cripple Creek, and died in 1902. William B. Chamberlain, later county treasurer and manager of the Douglas County Mercantile, owned it from 1888 to 1945 and built the additions. In 1984 the owner asked the town to move the house or see it torn down; the town bought it, hoping for a museum, but voters turned down a mill levy and it was sold in 1985. The National Register nomination calls it the last property in the Craig and Gould neighborhood still on its original parcel with all its outbuildings; it was listed on Dec. 13, 2016 (NRHP 16000836, S-0292). The nomination, citing Dyer's 1902 obituary, says he lost his right leg at Fredericksburg; Appleby's 1995 thesis has him losing his left foot at Chancellorsville (S-0291, p. 49). From the abstract of title, Lowenberg's students have Gould selling lots 6 and 7 to Samuel Dyer for $25 on Oct. 15, 1874, and Esther Dyer selling lots 4-6 to William B. Chamberlain for $1,000 on Feb. 18, 1888; Samuel E. Taylor of Monument married the Dyers on June 2, 1881. They heard that the stone outbuilding stored milk, meat and coal, and that the frame ones served as barn, carriage house and slaughterhouse (Lowenberg's Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (1980), pp. 89-92, S-0300). Their view that the middle section is the oldest, and their concrete foundation, are outliers to the nomination's cornerstone and survey (S-0292).
People
- Jeremiah M. Gould (1837–1903): sold Dyer the lots, 1874
Where it was
The National Register nomination's UTM reference (zone 13, 512415 E, 4358035 N, NAD83; S-0292), converted to latitude and longitude; it falls on the house, 111 feet from an interpolated street-range point for 208 N. Cantril St. Good to a hundred feet.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0291: Susan K. Appleby, "Douglas County: History and Guide to Cultural Resources" (M.A. thesis, History, University of Colorado at Denver, 1995; directed by Thomas J. Noel), x + 337 PDF pp.
- S-0292: Barbara Darden (Scheuber + Darden Architects, for the owners), National Register of Historic Places Registration Form, Samuel Dyer Residence (5DA.653), 208 North Cantril Street, Castle Rock, Douglas County (June 3, 2016; listed Dec. 13, 2016, NRIS 16000836)
- S-0300: Robert Lowenberg and his "What is History?" classes at Douglas County High School, Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (Castle Rock, Colo.: Robert L. Lowenberg, first printing 1980), 175 pp.
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.
Photographs at Douglas County Libraries
Held by the library's Archives and Local History in Castle Rock. The links open the library's records.
From the Photograph Collection:
- Dyer House, 2006-02-08