What we know
The Rock Island's depot was named Mayfield; the post office refused the name; PO Peyton from Feb. 14, 1889. Census, Peyton precinct: 41 in 1890, 464 in 1900, 299 in 1910 (S-0154). Grace Church, Colorado Springs, kept an Episcopal mission at Peyton from 1898 to 1909 (Breck, p. 131, S-0208); the diocese still listed Peyton among its unorganized missions in 1910 and 1911 (council journals, S-0206). In 1902 a ranch telephone line over fence wires ran 125 miles through Douglas, Elbert and El Paso counties from Castle Rock to 'the Calhan-Peyton area,' a call costing 25 cents (Castle Rock Journal, June 6, 1902, via Lowenberg's Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (1980), p. 31, S-0300); its route is not given. The town was laid out on Christmas Day 1888 on land George Peyton had pre-empted; the Rock Island paid for the survey and plat and 'received 51 percent of the revenue received on the sale of the lots,' and 'Mayfield' was refused 'because there was a Mayfield, California.' The first school, in 1888, was a herder's shanty 'about one-half mile west of the headquarters of the Brackett Sheep ranch,' owned by the Potomac Livestock Company (Breckenridge, S-0384, pp. 261-62). King's history of Calhan: the Calhan Methodists bought the Rock Island depot in 1956 for its lumber (King, S-0390, p. 68). The Farmers State Bank, incorporated in August 1916, was robbed in 1923 and 1934 and moved its charter to Calhan in 1934 or 1936 (pp. 15, 153, 206). In 1917 the town had the farmers' co-op elevator, the Peyton Hotel, the Russell Gates store (A. L. Peters, manager), J. W. Dickinson's store and Hamlin's garage (p. 45). Scott Peyton was George Peyton's brother, and both were sons of Stephen W. Peyton (p. 219). The 1937 Calhan News calls the settlement 'Mayfield' (p. 87). The Sayleses lived at Peyton from 1888 to 1895 (p. 213), and about 1890 Paradis and Moler women cooked for the section hands (p. 203). John O. Phillips, two miles north of Peyton, held the bank from 1923 (p. 205). He is not the J. O. Phillips who was Bijou Basin's postmaster until 1898, the rancher James O. Phillips, born in 1840 (Portrait and Biographical Record, 1898, S-0191, p. 1247); King has John O. in the state House and Senate from 1952 to 1960 and dying in 1964 (p. 153). Postmasters (register via Bauer, S-0395): Charles G. McGhee (Feb. 14, 1889), James McDermott (1892), Edgar Wise (1897), Junius W. Dickinson (1900; Bauer 'Junius M.', against the forms and King), Joseph C. Zimmerman (1915), 'Roay' A. Dickinson (1922, as printed), Amos A. Spear (1927), Grace W. Sayles (1929), Dennis A. Burroughs (1933), Mrs. Alice K. Lennhoff and Roy H. Zaabel (1942), Mrs. Irma G. Duncan (1947), John C. Lough (1956) and Joseph P. Davis (1957). The office stayed in the SE1/4 of Sec. 6 from 1888 to 1941, 323 to 380 feet from the Rock Island, and a cover of March 30, 1899 bears the Russell Gates Mercantile Co.'s Peyton corner card (Bauer). Bauer's 1997 photograph of a former post office building does not say which building it is.
Today: Census-designated place
Where it was
USGS GNIS Populated Place 204796
The U.S. Geological Survey's official point for this place name.
Sources
- S-0006: USGS Geographic Names Information System, Colorado file, 2021-08-25 edition
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0037: Henry Gannett, A Gazetteer of Colorado, USGS Bulletin 291 (1906)
- S-0040: Colorado railroad regulators' reports
- S-0044: Books to borrow on the Internet Archive (controlled lending, in copyright)
- S-0049: The New Falcon Herald local-history articles
- S-0064: Wikipedia, "List of post offices in Colorado" (A–F, G–O, P–Z) and town articles
- S-0065: Colorado Council of Genealogical Societies, Place Names of Colorado (1999), PDF hosted by the Denver Public Library
- S-0066: Jim Forte Postal History, U.S. post office database (postalhistory.com)
- S-0067: USPS Postmaster Finder (webpmt.usps.gov)
- S-0113: U.S. Post Office Department, Reports of Site Locations, 1837–1950 (NARA microfilm M1126), Colorado rolls 73 and 74: Douglas, Elbert and El Paso counties
- S-0154: U.S. Census, population of counties by minor civil divisions, 1890-1930 (Colorado tables)
- S-0191: Portrait and Biographical Record of Denver and Vicinity, Colorado (Chicago: Chapman Publishing Company, 1898)
- S-0206: Diocese of Colorado (Episcopal), Journal of the Annual Council, 1888-1896, 1900-1905, 1906-1909 and 1910-1913 (bound volumes scanned by Google from New York Public Library copies)
- S-0208: Allen du Pont Breck, The Episcopal Church in Colorado, 1860-1963 (Denver: Big Mountain Press, 1963)
- S-0300: Robert Lowenberg and his "What is History?" classes at Douglas County High School, Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (Castle Rock, Colo.: Robert L. Lowenberg, first printing 1980), 175 pp.
- S-0384: Juanita L. and John P. Breckenridge, El Paso County Heritage (Curtis Media Corporation, 1985; ISBN 0-88107-044-0)
- S-0390: Larry L. King, The History of Calhan and Vicinity, 1888–1988 (Simla, Colo.: Gaddy Printing Company, 1987), ISBN 0-9619442-0-X; LCCN 87-32719
- S-0395: William H. Bauer, Colorado Postal Encyclopedia: El Paso County, revised digital edition (Colorado Postal History Society, coloradopostalhistorysociety.com; revised by Steve Morehead, about 2017)
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.