Palmer Divide Research Project

Keystone Hotel

Keystone Hotel is a place still there today in Douglas County, Colorado, on the Palmer Divide, listed here under stores, hotels and other businesses before 1950.

Also: the Castle Cafe

What we know

Built in 1901 by James and Francis Fetherolf: thirteen rooms over the Tivoli Saloon, with a dance hall upstairs. The M & N Hotel and Cafe from 1930, then the Castle Cafe from the mid-1930s (county map, S-0123, citing Appleby, Fading Past, 2001). The Sanborn maps show a frame post office and drugstore on this corner in Sept. 1895; a stone saloon by Nov. 1902; 'Sal. & Hotel' (saloon and hotel) in July 1907; and a general store in the stone building in Sept. 1914. The 1914 building falls about 13 feet from the county's pin (S-0190). It was listed on the National Register on June 20, 1997, at 219 and 223 Fourth St.; the listing's coordinates fall within about 100 feet of this pin (National Register list, via S-0199). Appleby's 1995 thesis gives 1904 (S-0291, p. 38), from Lowenberg's Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (1980), whose students had the date from interviews (p. 52, S-0300); the stone saloon on the Nov. 1902 Sanborn map (S-0190) supports 1901. The same book has the Fetherolfs buying the lot from Henry Craig in 1889, and the upstairs dance hall on a monthly circuit with Sedalia, Parker and the Pikes Peak Grange hall near Franktown (pp. 52-53). Appleby's Fading Past (2001) gives 1901 in its heading, without a source (p. 26, S-0303), and puts the filling of the ground-floor windows in the mid-1960s, against the 1946 remodel (p. 27). Two frame buildings were moved off this corner when the stone building went up: James E. Fetherolf moved one to 211 Fourth St. in May 1901 (Castle Rock Journal, via the town's survey, 5DA.2667), and the survey of 213-215 Fourth St. says its west building came from the east as well (5DA.1259; S-0418). Both are mapped. A gathering place for quarry workers, it was reputed the 'wildest' in the area, and an extra deputy was hired for paydays (Jacobsen and Rocco-McKeel, Douglas County, 2023, p. 28, S-0423).

Where it was

Pin on the Douglas County Historic Resource Map (DCHR-050; Douglas County and Douglas County Libraries, 2012, on the Larkspur Historical Society's Google map, S-0123). Where that map and ours place the same site, the pins mostly fall within about 300 feet. Good to a few hundred feet.

Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.

See it on the map

Sources

  • S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
  • S-0045: Larkspur Historical Society website (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org)
  • S-0046: Douglas County Libraries, Archives & Local History: "Douglas County Timeline," "Douglas County Historic Sites," "Douglas County Schools Overview" (research collection PDFs 2, 7, 6)
  • S-0123: Douglas County Historic Resource Map (Douglas County Community Planning and Sustainable Development, the Douglas County History Research Center of Douglas County Libraries, and the Douglas County Historic Preservation Board, 2012), as put on Google Maps and Google Earth by the Larkspur Historical Society
  • S-0190: Sanborn-Perris Map Co. and Sanborn Map Co., Castle Rock, Douglas County, Colorado, fire-insurance maps, two sheets each: July 1890, September 1895, November 1902, July 1907 and September 1914 (Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division, Sanborn Maps collection)
  • S-0199: Larkspur Historical Society, the document store behind its "LHS Search Agent" (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org/resources/lhs-search-agents/): 362 files, about 810 MB, uploaded April–June 2026
  • S-0291: Susan K. Appleby, "Douglas County: History and Guide to Cultural Resources" (M.A. thesis, History, University of Colorado at Denver, 1995; directed by Thomas J. Noel), x + 337 PDF pp.
  • S-0300: Robert Lowenberg and his "What is History?" classes at Douglas County High School, Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (Castle Rock, Colo.: Robert L. Lowenberg, first printing 1980), 175 pp.
  • S-0303: Susan Consola Appleby, Fading Past: The Story of Douglas County, Colorado (Palmer Lake: Filter Press, 2001; ISBN 0-86541-060-7), x + 210 pp.
  • S-0418: Town of Castle Rock, Survey of Historic Resources: Colorado Cultural Resource Survey architectural inventory forms, 2007-2016 (recorder Barbara Darden, Scheuber + Darden Architects), Town of Castle Rock Historic Building Site Files, Douglas County Libraries
  • S-0423: Jean Jacobsen and Susan Rocco-McKeel, Douglas County (Past & Present series; Charleston: Arcadia Publishing, 2023)

Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.

Photographs at Douglas County Libraries

Held by the library's Archives and Local History in Castle Rock. The links open the library's records.

From the Photograph Collection:

Know more about Keystone Hotel?

Corrections, family stories, photographs, deeds, letters and maps are all welcome. Messages and files come to Michael Christensen privately; nothing appears on the site until it has been checked, and you'll be credited the way you ask.