What we know
'Two men were killed at Spring Valley, and two horses stolen; and two men were killed at Buzzard's station. One of those killed at Spring Valley was Jotham Lincoln … He was binding oats when the Indians rode up to him and shot him down. They ran off thirteen horses' (Rocky Mountain News, Sept. 5, 1868). The full item calls him 'Jotham Lincoln, brother of Mr. J. F. Lincoln, of this town [Denver]' (transcription in Larkspur binder 6, p. 6, S-0005), and the two brothers are named together on the 1869 patent for this land (S-0080). The three raiders 'were riding along the stage road' (News, Sept. 11); the stage line's own horses were taken at Spring Valley (Weekly News, Sept. 9). No election was held at Spring Valley that month. Lincoln's ranch buildings stood where Louis Killin's later stood (Margaret Smith of Larkspur, in an undated newspaper item, S-0199), and the Larkspur Historical Society's ranch list equates the Lincoln and Killin ranches. Lincoln Mountain (USGS GNIS summit, 39.174, -104.759), a mile north of this point, is named for him, and he is said to be buried on it: Marr has him buried on a nearby hillside, 'and the mountain today bears his name' (Marr, S-0185, p. 48), and an undated newspaper clipping in the Larkspur binders puts the grave 'south of the Remington Ranch' (binder 6, p. 82, S-0005); his funeral was held at J. F. Lincoln's in Denver, so the grave story is uncertain. Marr calls him Jonathan, puts the killing in 'the summer of 1867' and has a Mexican working beside him escape (Marr, S-0185, p. 48; the page is also reproduced in the 2009 county landmark nomination, S-0199), but in her account of 1868, following Howbert, she has Jonathan Lincoln killed at Spring Valley 'By the first of September' (p. 88), so she gives both years; Koch also names him Jonathan, killed in 1865 while plowing and buried on top of the mountain (S-0197, pp. 14, 52), and the key to her pioneer map gives Joseph Lincoln, 1867; see Lincoln Mountain. The 1868 newspaper, the 2009 nomination and the society's Spring Valley timeline give 1868, and the newspaper record supports it.
Where it was
Placed at GNIS's Lincoln Ranch (Locale), 0.7 mile north of the Spring Valley store site. The dispatch says only 'at Spring Valley'; that GNIS's Lincoln Ranch is Jotham Lincoln's field is a guess, so treat the point as 'Spring Valley, within about a mile'. Checked 2026-10-11: the point falls on the Lincoln brothers' own land, the NW SE of Sec. 22, T10S R66W, part of a military-warrant patent of Oct. 1, 1869 to Joseph F. Lincoln, Jotham Lincoln, Elvira C. and Jacob B. Strahan and Elias W. Tuttle (N1/2 SE and SW SE Sec. 22; doc. 78741); Joseph F. Lincoln also patented SE NE Sec. 22 and N1/2 NW Sec. 23 in 1867, with Martha E. Grose (doc. 89894) (BLM GLO, S-0080). So 'at Spring Valley' can be read as on this land, good to about a quarter mile.
Placed from a written description, such as a land section, a distance from a landmark or an old survey note.
Sources
- S-0005: Larkspur Historical Society, "Historical Site Survey Binders"
- S-0006: USGS Geographic Names Information System, Colorado file, 2021-08-25 edition
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0028: Irving Howbert, The Indians of the Pike's Peak Region: Including an Account of the Battle of Sand Creek, and of Occurrences in El Paso County, Colorado, during the War with the Cheyennes and Arapahoes, in 1864 and 1868 (The Knickerbocker Press, New York, 1914)
- S-0045: Larkspur Historical Society website (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org)
- S-0080: General Land Office land patents, Bureau of Land Management (glorecords.blm.gov)
- S-0092: The September 1868 raids in the newspapers (via S-0016)
- S-0185: Josephine Lowell Marr, Douglas County: A Historical Journey (1983)
- S-0197: Susan E. (Steppler) Koch, The Land Is In My Blood: The History of The Divide Country and Its Pioneers, complete with Driving Tour and Homestead Maps (self-published; copyright 2015, U.S. Copyright Office TXu 2-251-186; first printing 2008, second October 2015, this copy the third printing, fall 2018)
- S-0199: Larkspur Historical Society, the document store behind its "LHS Search Agent" (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org/resources/lhs-search-agents/): 362 files, about 810 MB, uploaded April–June 2026
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.