What we know
Where, by tradition, a posse hanged the second of two men accused of murdering a homesteader in November 1867: 'a half or three-quarters of a mile north of Castle Rock … I remember …' (Charles A. Nickson, 1963, Larkspur Historical Society binder 1 p. 83); 'Hangman's Gulch just north of Castle Rock, and close to the scene of the crime' (Albert Dakan, 1941, Larkspur Historical Society binder 10 p. 29; also Vauna Schultz's 1947 Colorado Magazine interview with him). Dakan says the body washed out of the gulch bank and the skeleton hung in the Castle Rock school. Shaun Boyd, the Douglas County archivist, found no record of the hanging, no names, and a doubtful date for the school fire (Town of Castle Rock, Oct. 3, 2016). A legend tied to a place, not a documented execution. The first man was hanged near Palmer Lake (unplaced). Marr, citing the 1947 Colorado Magazine (May 1947, p. 123), puts the murder on East Plum Creek in November 1867; the posse caught the two strangers near the present site of Monument and hanged the first 'a mile or two north of Palmer' Lake, then hanged the second from a stout limb of a large yellow pine in a gulch 'about a mile north of Castle Rock,' not far from the murdered homesteader's ranch, and buried him in the bank of a sand gulch. Floods later exposed the skeleton, which was used in the school's physiology classes until the frame school burned in 1896 (Marr, S-0185, p. 169).
People
- Albert Dakan (1867–1951): told the story in 1941 and 1946
Where it was
USGS GNIS valley 'Hangmans Gulch', Douglas County (2021 Colorado file, S-0007), 1.3 miles north of Castle Rock. The gulch, not the tree.
Sources
- S-0005: Larkspur Historical Society, "Historical Site Survey Binders"
- S-0006: USGS Geographic Names Information System, Colorado file, 2021-08-25 edition
- S-0007: USGS GNIS DomesticNames, Colorado (current edition)
- S-0072: The Colorado Magazine (State Historical Society of Colorado), 30 issues 1931–1977, full text
- S-0160: Web pages on violent-death sites, read 2026-10-07
- S-0185: Josephine Lowell Marr, Douglas County: A Historical Journey (1983)
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.