Palmer Divide Research Project

Fagan's Grave

Fagan's Grave is a historic or vanished place in El Paso County, Colorado, on the Palmer Divide, listed here under cemeteries.

Also: O'Falley's Grave (1858)

CemeteriesHistoric or vanishedEl Paso County

What we know

The grave of a man who froze to death in the snowstorm of April 29 to May 2, 1858, which caught Col. William W. Loring's column of the Utah expedition camped at 'Point of Rocks… on the dividing ridge between the Arkansas and the South Fork of the Platte.' Loring reported that 'a citizen teamster in the quartermaster's employ was frozen to death' but gave no name, and at least one of Capt. Randolph Marcy's herders died in the same storm (Annual Report of the Secretary of War, 1858, pp. 183, 193; S-0364). On June 21, 1858, Luke Tierney passed 'a perpendicular rock, five hundred feet high, at the base of which was a tomb of recent origin,' with a wooden cross reading 'Charles Michael Fagan-1858' (Tierney 1859, p. 9; S-0365). Augustus Voorhees called it 'O'Falley's Grave' in 1858, twelve miles along the trail from Marcy's camps (von Ahlefeldt, S-0009, pp. 20-21), and William B. Parsons's guide of that year says 'O'Falley was one of the victims of Col. Loring's march' (S-0366, p. 30). By 1859 travelers wrote 'Fagan': on June 10, 1859, George M. Willing passed 'the grave of a man named Fagan' who had frozen to death the May before (S-0367, p. 373). Its headstone faced south below the Point of Rocks in 1979 (von Ahlefeldt pp. 20-21). A 1950 account built on F. W. Cragin's research dates the teamster's death to May 1, 1858, and says the grave 'was marked with a pile of stones, which is there to this day' (Dorothy Price Shaw, Colorado Magazine, Jan. 1950, p. 70; S-0369). Recent histories give 'May 2, 1858' for the cross, a date no 1858 record found so far supports (New Falcon Herald, Oct. 2008, S-0049; Fletcher, S-0368). On private land. Ellen Hunt, coming north from Fountain City with her husband's wagon party, traveled 15 miles before breakfast on June 25, 1859 to 'a pine forest—very beautiful but sad from the number of graves here.' Eight graves were 'in view of persons who have frozen to death, one as late as June third, '59.' Horseflies drew blood from the cattle 'while passing through the pines.' Hafen's note identifies the place as Fagan's Grave; she does not name it (her diary, Colorado Magazine, Sept. 1944, p. 168 and n. 14, S-0072). Her camp of the night before was probably Jimmy's Camp (see Jimmy Camp spring), about 18 miles from this point in a straight line. Julia Lambert's family, bound from Colorado City to Denver in July 1860, had 'to cross the divide between the Arkansas and the Platte rivers'; camped for dinner 'on high ground,' they came upon three graves, with a board at the head inscribed 'Frozen to death on May 3rd, 1860.' Their next camp was on Cherry Creek (Lambert in The Trail, 1916, printed in Lambert and Broome, Plain Tales of the Plains, 2025, S-0412, pp. 22-23, 25). Broome takes the graves for this site (n. 22), and a road that ends on Cherry Creek fits; that they were these graves is our reading, and no other source we hold names a death here in May 1860. Broome puts the site 'near today’s Kiowa'; it is on Kiowa Creek, about 18 miles south of the town. His 'Mrs. A. C. Hunt,' for whom he found no source, is Ellen Hunt's diary, above.

People

Where it was

'Fagan's Grave Camping Place': Scott, Historic Trail Map of the Denver 1x2 Quadrangle (USGS I-2639, 1999, S-0106), symbol read from the reprojected sheet (good to a few hundred feet); beside Kiowa Creek just west of Scott's Point of Rocks. 'Along the Jimmy Camp Trail on the west bank of Kiowa Creek near the Point of Rocks' (von Ahlefeldt p. 20, photo p. 21); the 1987 Black Forest plan's Map 2 No. 25.

Read from Glenn R. Scott's USGS historic trail map of 1999 and confirmed by a second, independent source.

See it on the map

Sources

  • S-0009: Judy von Ahlefeldt, Thunder, Sun and Snow: The History of Colorado's Black Forest (Colorado Springs: Century One Press, a division of Graphic Services, Inc., 1979)
  • S-0049: The New Falcon Herald local-history articles
  • S-0050: Black Forest Preservation Plan, chapter 2, and Black Forest Community Club history (Anna Mae Hawkins, 1986), as posted on dawog.net
  • S-0072: The Colorado Magazine (State Historical Society of Colorado), 30 issues 1931–1977, full text
  • S-0082: Jeff Broome, "Indian Massacres in Elbert County, Colorado: New Information on the 1864 Hungate and 1868 Dietemann Murders," Denver Westerners Roundup 60, no. 1 (Jan.–Feb. 2004), reprinted on kclonewolf.com
  • S-0101: Elaine Freed and David Barber, Historic Sites & Structures, El Paso County, Colorado ([Colorado Springs]: prepared for the El Paso County Land Use Department, [1977]), 56 pp., with the survey photographs in PPLD's Historic Sites and Structures collection
  • S-0106: Glenn R. Scott, Historic Trail Map of the Denver 1° × 2° Quadrangle, Central Colorado (USGS Miscellaneous Investigations Series Map I-2639)
  • S-0364: Annual Report of the Secretary of War, 1858 (Sen. Ex. Doc. 1, pt. 2, 35th Cong., 2d sess., serial 975), No. 87, Col. W. W. Loring to Army Headquarters, Camp Scott, June 11, 1858 (pp. 182–84), and No. 88, Capt. R. B. Marcy to Maj. Porter, June 12, 1858 (pp. 192–94)
  • S-0365: Luke D. Tierney, History of the Gold Discoveries on the South Platte River (Pacific City, Iowa, 1859), facsimile reprint by Nolie Mumey (Denver, n.d.), 27 pp.
  • S-0366: William B. Parsons, The Gold Mines of Western Kansas (Lawrence, Kansas: printed for the author at the Lawrence Republican, 1858)
  • S-0367: George M. Willing, "Diary of a Journey to the Pike's Peak Gold Mines in 1859," ed. Ralph P. Bieber, Mississippi Valley Historical Review 14, no. 3 (Dec. 1927), beginning on p. 360
  • S-0368: Jack and Pat Fletcher, "Fagan's Grave," Cherokee Trail website (Butler Community College), https://cherokeetrail.butlercc.edu/TrailSites/fagangrave.htm
  • S-0369: Dorothy Price Shaw, "Jimmy's Camp on the Cherokee Trail," The Colorado Magazine 27, no. 1 (January 1950): 63–72
  • S-0412: Julia S. Lambert and Jeff Broome, Plain Tales of the Plains: Indian Raids and Captivity, Pioneer Life and Trail Tales in Early Colorado Territory (Pueblo: Pueblo County Historical Society, 2025)

Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.

Know more about Fagan's Grave?

Corrections, family stories, photographs, deeds, letters and maps are all welcome. Messages and files come to Michael Christensen privately; nothing appears on the site until it has been checked, and you'll be credited the way you ask.