Palmer Divide Research Project

Eastonville

Eastonville is a historic or vanished place in El Paso County, Colorado, on the Palmer Divide, listed here under towns and settlements.

Also: Easton · McConnellsville

Towns and settlementsHistoric or vanishedEl Paso County

What we know

The D&NO station of 1882 was McConnellsville: 64 miles from Denver 'on summit of the Divide', about 150 residents in July 1882. Easton's post office moved to it and, said Hobbs, was renamed Eastonville because 'Easton' was too like 'Eaton'. PO Eastonville 1883-1932; Hobbs (1950) on its trains, stores and the 1935 flood. No Colorado & Southern train ran south of Eastonville from Oct. 31, 1911 until May 16, 1913, when the state commission ordered service to Falcon restored; in 1916 the town had 'only about one hundred people' (S-0143). The Eastonville Brick Company opened a 100-acre clay pit a quarter mile from town in 1902 (S-0143). Easton's earlier post office sites (Weir's Mill, 1872, and Goodrich's place) are mapped separately. Cemetery at 39.016, -104.606. Census (precinct, village and farms together): 149 in 1890, 293 in 1900, 254 in 1910; the precinct lines were redrawn before each census, and after 1910 El Paso's rural precincts carry numbers only (S-0154). Cora Deane Younger, born in 1906, remembered it as her family's town: they hauled milk to the creamery by wagon or sleigh and bought their groceries there; Mrs. Killen worked in the store, and the Higbys had had a store there; a Dr. Kethinger (spelling uncertain) and a Dr. Anderson practiced there. When she was in about the seventh grade (about 1918-19) the country districts consolidated with Eastonville, whose school had a four-year high school in four rooms, two up and two down, and a bus, 'a truck with flappy curtains' (DCL oral history doh/827, 1993, S-0213). Its high school still played in the eastern county basketball league of the 1930s and 1940s, with Calhan, Ramah, Alta Vista and Falcon, 'until it closed' (Conarroe, S-0249, p. 115). The Castle Rock Journal of June 6, 1902 reported a new telephone line between Monument and Eastonville (CHNC, S-0268). Mathews (1969): it called itself the 'Potato Capital of the World'; Russell Gates's big store made it the busiest town on the C&S line until his larger Elbert store opened in 1906; the church Mullaney and Whitmore built in 1887 was 'about the only building left' after the Memorial Day flood of 1935 and the years of moving away (S-0020, pp. 41-42, 46). Jones: milepost 64.1, with a depot, a two-story section house, a stockyard, a 920-foot siding and a wye of 1911; the 1935 flood cut the line north and south of town (Jones, Colorado & Southern Railway's D&NO Route, 2022, S-0311, pp. 16, 110, 198). Apex, the line's summit, is 1.1 miles north (mapped). Its people called it 'the potato capital of the world,' and the Colorado Implement Manufacturing Co. made potato shakers there (Eberhart, Ghosts of the Colorado Plains, 1986, p. 50, S-0035). After a Knights of Pythias dance in the opera house on Oct. 28, 1898, Victor Tipton, 20, died the morning after a fight; an autopsy found a blood clot on the heart. Three young men were indicted, and in January 1899 the judge directed a verdict of not guilty for want of evidence (Elbert County Tribune and Rocky Mountain News, Nov. 1898-Jan. 1899, S-0371). The pine forest's edge, about three miles west of town, was still advancing slowly into the grassland in the early 1940s: one pine about 100 yards inside the edge, 40 inches through and short and stocky from growing in the open, 'had obviously been a migrant about 200 years ago' (Robert B. Livingston, Ecological Monographs 19, 1949, pp. 139-40, S-0025). King's history of Calhan: the Gammons freighted from Eastonville to O. Z. in the 1870s and 1880s, and Eli Woodring freighted between Calhan and Eastonville from 1889 (King, S-0390, pp. 98, 238); in the 1890s the Balsicks' potatoes went to Eastonville for shipment to Pueblo (p. 136). The Iowa colony of 1890 came because potatoes grew 'on the hills at Eastonville and Monument' (p. 90). J. B. King published the Eastonville World in 1896 (p. 91), and the town had a creamery in 1901 (p. 103). Postmasters (register via Bauer, S-0395): John M. Brazelton (1883), Frank B. Hall (1887), Warren Eddy (1889), 'Albert B. Whitman' (1890; probably A. B. Whitmore, who filled in the 1887 form, I), Alva M. Barnett (1894), Walter Whitmore (1898-1914), Belle H. and Leslie W. Meyer (1914), John H. Ragsdale (1915), Mrs. Alice J. Milan (1930) and Mrs. Mabel L. Ross (acting, April 1932); discontinued May 11, 1932, mail to Peyton. Bauer's 1925 for the flood is a slip for 1935.

People

  • Ross Barrett (1907–1975): pupil in 1921; long-time resident of the area
  • Dr. Bean (active 1899–1905): physician, about 1899
  • John M. Brazelton (active 1882–1887): owned its first store; postmaster, 1882-83
  • Cy Cole (1894–1974): rancher north of the town, 1920s-1950s
  • Jack Dawson (active 1909): one of the men who ran the butcher shop
  • Jim Foster (active 1900): one of the men who ran the butcher shop
  • John Gates (active 1883–1903): storekeeper; bought Brazelton's store with Orlin Gates
  • Orlin Gates (active 1891): storekeeper; homestead east of the town, patented 1891
  • J. W. Higby (1854–1916): partner in the Russell-Gates store, 1888-1900
  • Charles M. Hobbs (1875–1967): lived in the community 25 years; wrote its history, 1950
  • James T. Hobbs (active 1869–1900): his son born just south of the later town, 1875
  • J. D. Kessinger (active 1905–1909): physician, 1905 to about 1909
  • Joel B. King (1849–1909): published the Eastonville World
  • William H. Macomber (1839–1922): his Shadeland Ranch lay near the town, 1880s-1890
  • Charles Mullaney (active 1887–1899): carpenter; built the Presbyterian church with Charles Whitmore, 1887; justice of the peace, 1899
  • Alfred Peterson (1844–1921): raced his trotter Old Blue at the town's track
  • Frank Phillips (active 1899): constable, 1899; one of the men who ran the butcher shop
  • Elias Roberts (1842–1931): his preemption claim nearby, 1873-78; later land near the town
  • Carrie Opal Jessup Sellers (1899–1971): lived in and near the town from 1901; drew its map in 1912
  • Jess Sellers (1894–1968): farm hand, about 1918
  • Ernest L. Shadomy (active 1910s): Colorado and Southern station agent, before 1917
  • Dr. Skidmore (active 1899–1905): physician, between Dr. Bean and Dr. Kessinger
  • Albert B. Whitmore (1853–1943): postmaster, 1890-94
  • Charles Whitmore (1850–1923): carpenter; built the Presbyterian church, 1887
  • Norman Whitmore (1899–1990): grew up here; recalled the town of the early 1900s
  • Walter Whitmore (1859–1929): storekeeper and druggist; postmaster 1898-1914

Where it was

USGS GNIS Populated Place 193298

The U.S. Geological Survey's official point for this place name.

See it on the map

Sources

  • S-0006: USGS Geographic Names Information System, Colorado file, 2021-08-25 edition
  • S-0009: Judy von Ahlefeldt, Thunder, Sun and Snow: The History of Colorado's Black Forest (Colorado Springs: Century One Press, a division of Graphic Services, Inc., 1979)
  • S-0013: Lucille Lavelett, Monument's Faded Neighboring Communities and Its Folklore: Pring, Husted, Gwillimville, Table Rock, Spring Valley, Greenland (Colorado Springs: printed by ABC Printing, 1979), 70, [40] p., illus., map, facsims.; page numbers cited are those of the third printing (Palmer Lake Historical Society, 2026), which is paged differently from the 1979 printing
  • S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
  • S-0020: Carl F. Mathews and E.C. Matthews, Early Days Around the Divide (St. Louis: Sign Book Co., [1969]), 78 p., illus., map, ports.
  • S-0025: R.B. Livingston, "An Ecological Study of the Black Forest Region and Adjacent Plains" (PhD dissertation, Duke University, 1947) and "An Ecological Study of the Black Forest, Colorado," Ecological Monographs 19:123–144 (1949)
  • S-0035: Perry Eberhart, Ghosts of the Colorado Plains (Athens, Ohio: Swallow Press/Ohio University Press, 1986; ISBN 0-8040-0832-9)
  • S-0036: George A. Crofutt, Crofutt's Grip-Sack Guide of Colorado (1881)
  • S-0037: Henry Gannett, A Gazetteer of Colorado, USGS Bulletin 291 (1906)
  • S-0040: Colorado railroad regulators' reports
  • S-0044: Books to borrow on the Internet Archive (controlled lending, in copyright)
  • S-0046: Douglas County Libraries, Archives & Local History: "Douglas County Timeline," "Douglas County Historic Sites," "Douglas County Schools Overview" (research collection PDFs 2, 7, 6)
  • S-0049: The New Falcon Herald local-history articles
  • S-0050: Black Forest Preservation Plan, chapter 2, and Black Forest Community Club history (Anna Mae Hawkins, 1986), as posted on dawog.net
  • S-0054: Chas. M. Hobbs, "History of Eastonville, Colorado," The Colorado Magazine 27, no. 3 (July 1950), pp. 208–211
  • S-0058: Frank Hall, History of the State of Colorado, vol. 3 (1891) and vol. 4 (1895)
  • S-0064: Wikipedia, "List of post offices in Colorado" (A–F, G–O, P–Z) and town articles
  • S-0065: Colorado Council of Genealogical Societies, Place Names of Colorado (1999), PDF hosted by the Denver Public Library
  • S-0066: Jim Forte Postal History, U.S. post office database (postalhistory.com)
  • S-0068: U.S. Postal Bulletin (Post Office Department daily orders), 1880s–1950s issues
  • S-0069: COGenWeb El Paso County community lists and Lincoln County history
  • S-0078: Easton, McConnellsville and Eastonville in the newspapers, 1873–1884, and the Hobbs reprints of 1965 and 1971 (via S-0016)
  • S-0080: General Land Office land patents, Bureau of Land Management (glorecords.blm.gov)
  • S-0113: U.S. Post Office Department, Reports of Site Locations, 1837–1950 (NARA microfilm M1126), Colorado rolls 73 and 74: Douglas, Elbert and El Paso counties
  • S-0143: Eastonville in the Colorado newspapers, 1872–1960: headline sweep (CHNC)
  • S-0154: U.S. Census, population of counties by minor civil divisions, 1890-1930 (Colorado tables)
  • S-0183: Michael Weinfeld and John Howe, Shootouts, Killings, and War Heroes: The History Hidden in Monument's Cemetery (Westcliffe, Colo.: Filter Press, 2024)
  • S-0213: Douglas County Libraries, Archives & Local History, digital archive (archives.dcl.org, CONTENTdm cdm17197): item records of all 15 collections
  • S-0249: Percy Conarroe, Calhan: Life in a Small Town on the Plains of Eastern Colorado (Lafayette, Colo.: 6000 Bees LLC, 2005; 2nd printing or edition 2017)
  • S-0268: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection: the Weber and Schlupp leads, 1865–1965 (via S-0016)
  • S-0311: James R. "Jim" Jones, Colorado & Southern Railway's D&NO Route (Colchester, Vt.: Tell-Tale Productions, 2022), about 256 pp., ISBN 978-1-7348484-1-0
  • S-0371: Colorado Historic Newspapers: checks of Eberhart's leads (S-0035), 2026-10-30. The Tipton death at Eastonville (1898–99) and the Husted collision of Nov. 26, 1888
  • S-0390: Larry L. King, The History of Calhan and Vicinity, 1888–1988 (Simla, Colo.: Gaddy Printing Company, 1987), ISBN 0-9619442-0-X; LCCN 87-32719
  • S-0395: William H. Bauer, Colorado Postal Encyclopedia: El Paso County, revised digital edition (Colorado Postal History Society, coloradopostalhistorysociety.com; revised by Steve Morehead, about 2017)

Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.

1976 survey photographs

Taken for Elaine Freed and David Barber's survey of El Paso County's historic sites and held by the Pikes Peak Library District. The links open the library's records.

Know more about Eastonville?

Corrections, family stories, photographs, deeds, letters and maps are all welcome. Messages and files come to Michael Christensen privately; nothing appears on the site until it has been checked, and you'll be credited the way you ask.