What we know
Henrietta Dietemann and her son, about five, were killed and scalped while her husband was in Denver; her daughter, her sister-in-law Maria and two hired men escaped and reached Kiowa Station, about six miles off. Their bodies were shown in Denver (News, Sept. 2, 1868; von Ahlefeldt p. 24). Date: the settlers' petition of 'to-day … (twenty-fifth)' and the Weekly News's 'Tuesday' put the attack on Aug. 25 (News, Aug. 26 and Sept. 2, 1868); Scott's map, Howbert and Mathews (S-0020, pp. 14, 24) give Aug. 27. The contemporary papers are the better source, and the label follows them (changed 2026-10-25); the News of Aug. 27 again said 'Tuesday' (Perkins, D. C. Oakes, S-0316, p. 253). Henrietta was 30 and John 4 (death notice, News, Aug. 27, 1868, S-0328). The family had come only weeks before from 'the old Dietermann ranch' on Plum Creek (News, Sept. 25, 1868, S-0328) to two new houses on Comanche Creek about five miles east of Kiowa (Mrs. Fahrion's affidavit, via Broome, S-0326, p. 281). The News described the surviving daughter as 'considerably older than the murdered boy' (Aug. 27, 1868), against Broome's three-year-old (S-0326, p. 274). Broome's earlier book has the family arriving on June 19, 1868 from their place on Plum Creek, 'just north of present-day Castle Rock, from 1862 to 1868,' and a neighbor, Henry Smith, living alone 'about three miles south of them' (Cheyenne War, 2013, S-0340, pp. 370, 375; Broome's reading of the claims).
People
- J. George Benkelman (active 1862–1898): probably the inquest witness of 1868, whose Dry Creek camp was raided that morning
- Henrietta Dietermann (died 1868): killed here with her son, Aug. 25, 1868
- George Fahrion (1836–1909): with the party that found the bodies, by Hall's account
- Henry G. Smith (1834–1909): the fleeing party warned him at his house; his place was stripped in the raid
Where it was
Scott's X 'Dietemann Massacre Aug. 27, 1868', just west of Comanche Creek: Scott, Historic Trail Map of the Denver 1x2 Quadrangle (USGS I-2639, 1999, S-0106), symbol read from the reprojected sheet (good to a few hundred feet). The Weekly News had them 'killed near their house on Comanche Creek' (Sept. 2, 1868, S-0097), but the coroner's inquest in the News of Aug. 27 gave John Benkelman's testimony that 'The deceased were both about four miles from their home, in company with some others, trying to make their escape to a neighbour's house' (S-0328), as the depredation-claim affidavits of the survivors also say (Broome, Indian Raids and Massacres, 2020, S-0326, pp. 277-280). Scott's X fits a place a few miles up Comanche Creek from the house.
Read from Glenn R. Scott's USGS historic trail map of 1999 and confirmed by a second, independent source.
Sources
- S-0009: Judy von Ahlefeldt, Thunder, Sun and Snow: The History of Colorado's Black Forest (Colorado Springs: Century One Press, a division of Graphic Services, Inc., 1979)
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0020: Carl F. Mathews and E.C. Matthews, Early Days Around the Divide (St. Louis: Sign Book Co., [1969]), 78 p., illus., map, ports.
- S-0028: Irving Howbert, The Indians of the Pike's Peak Region: Including an Account of the Battle of Sand Creek, and of Occurrences in El Paso County, Colorado, during the War with the Cheyennes and Arapahoes, in 1864 and 1868 (The Knickerbocker Press, New York, 1914)
- S-0082: Jeff Broome, "Indian Massacres in Elbert County, Colorado: New Information on the 1864 Hungate and 1868 Dietemann Murders," Denver Westerners Roundup 60, no. 1 (Jan.–Feb. 2004), reprinted on kclonewolf.com
- S-0097: Bijou Basin and Gomer's Mill in the newspapers, 1868–1909 (via S-0016)
- S-0106: Glenn R. Scott, Historic Trail Map of the Denver 1° × 2° Quadrangle, Central Colorado (USGS Miscellaneous Investigations Series Map I-2639)
- S-0316: LaVonne J. Perkins, D. C. Oakes: Family, Friends & Foe (Stony Ridge Press, 2009; second edition 2011), 354 PDF pp. (printed pp. 1–352 approx.), ISBN 978-0-578-01602-3
- S-0326: Jeff Broome, Indian Raids and Massacres: Essays on the Central Plains Indian War (Caldwell, Idaho: Caxton Press, 2020), ISBN 978-0-87004-635-3
- S-0328: CHNC check of Broome's Hungate (1864) and 1868-war claims (newspapers, 2026-10-28)
- S-0340: Jeff Broome, Cheyenne War: Indian Raids on the Roads to Denver, 1864–1869 (Sheridan, Colo.: Aberdeen Books; Sterling: Logan County Historical Society, 2013), ISBN 978-0-9713852-4-5
Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.