Palmer Divide Research Project

City Hotel

City Hotel is a historic or vanished place in Douglas County, Colorado, on the Palmer Divide, listed here under stores, hotels and other businesses before 1950.

Stores, hotels and other businesses before 1950Historic or vanishedDouglas County

What we know

A frame hotel labeled 'City Hotel' on all five Sanborn maps, July 1890 to Sept. 1914: one and a half stories in 1890, two by 1914, when it was heated by stoves and lit by acetylene gas (S-0190). The maps name no proprietor. Lowenberg's students trace it to a hotel the carpenter John Harris built at New Memphis about 1872 for his brother Tom, moved to this site in 1877; Harris called it the Castle Rock House, and Philip Crawshaw, who bought it in 1889, enlarged it in 1890 and named it the City Hotel. Tom Harris, the town's second mayor, died in August 1884 after a runaway steer gored him in the street. Ole (Olf S.) Ellison bought the hotel from Mary Harris on April 12, 1888 and sold it to Crawshaw on June 7, 1889, though another chapter has his wife, Mary L. Ellison, buying it a few years before 1897. Clinton J. and Alma S. Towne owned it from 1908 to 1920, and Alma Towne again from about 1933 to 1943 (Lowenberg's Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (1980), pp. 41-45, 99, S-0300). Marr quotes the 1876 business directory, which lists the Castle Rock Hotel and the Foster Hotel, and adds that the Castle Rock Hotel 'had been moved from New Memphis by John Harris' (Marr, S-0185, p. 150), so the hotel was here by 1876 (the 1876 directory, as quoted by Marr), against the students' 1877; elsewhere she has the Harris brothers moving from New Memphis in 1874, with the hotel they moved with them, which 'still stands at 4th and Perry' (p. 160). She has Thomas Harris killed in 1884 by a runaway horse rather than a steer, and calls him a founder of New Memphis, in Colorado from 1871 (p. 160).

People

  • Mary Harris (active 1884–1888): kept it as the Castle Rock Hotel, 1884-88
  • Thomas S. Harris (1837–1884): kept it as the Castle Rock Hotel

Where it was

West side of Perry Street between Fourth and Fifth (block 12, lot 3 and the south 10 feet of lot 2, the assessor's description, in Lowenberg, S-0300, p. 46), on the Sanborn Fire Insurance Map of Castle Rock, sheet 1, Sept. 1914 (Library of Congress, S-0190); the July 1890 sheet puts it at the same point. Each sheet was placed by fitting it to today's Wilcox and Perry street crossings at 2nd to 5th streets (eight points, each within about 10 feet of the fit). Good to about a hundred feet.

See it on the map

Sources

  • S-0185: Josephine Lowell Marr, Douglas County: A Historical Journey (1983)
  • S-0190: Sanborn-Perris Map Co. and Sanborn Map Co., Castle Rock, Douglas County, Colorado, fire-insurance maps, two sheets each: July 1890, September 1895, November 1902, July 1907 and September 1914 (Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division, Sanborn Maps collection)
  • S-0291: Susan K. Appleby, "Douglas County: History and Guide to Cultural Resources" (M.A. thesis, History, University of Colorado at Denver, 1995; directed by Thomas J. Noel), x + 337 PDF pp.
  • S-0300: Robert Lowenberg and his "What is History?" classes at Douglas County High School, Castle Rock: A Grass Roots History (Castle Rock, Colo.: Robert L. Lowenberg, first printing 1980), 175 pp.

Sources are named in the text above. Numbers such as S-0080 refer to our source list. Most newspaper quotations were read in the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. Long quotations from recent books are shortened here.

Photographs and records at Douglas County Libraries

Held by the library's Archives and Local History in Castle Rock. The links open the library's records. The Town of Castle Rock's survey forms are architectural inventories of the building, with photographs.

From the Photograph Collection:

From the Town of Castle Rock Historic Building Site Files:

Know more about City Hotel?

Corrections, family stories, photographs, deeds, letters and maps are all welcome. Messages and files come to Michael Christensen privately; nothing appears on the site until it has been checked, and you'll be credited the way you ask.