Biography
Samuel P. Gutshall was born near Blain, Perry County, Pennsylvania, in April 1840. He served in the Ninth Pennsylvania Cavalry from 1861 until June 1865, under Buell in Kentucky, Rosecrans in Tennessee and Kilpatrick on Sherman's march, and was wounded in the right arm at Wilmington, North Carolina (History of the Arkansas Valley, 1881, S-0059, p. 335). The next spring he crossed the plains from Leavenworth with an ox train of Ben Holladay's, reaching Denver in July 1866, and after a few months near the city went onto the Divide, where he lived for six years (p. 335).
In 1870-72 he took up land on the Divide: with Thomas H. Smith (and, on one copy of the patent, Richard Kirk) 160 acres in Secs. 17 and 20, T11S R65W, at Table Rock, in May 1870; by cash entry land in Secs. 12, 15 and 22, T11S R66W, in 1870, and another tract in Sec. 17 in 1872 (BLM GLO, S-0080). His land in Sec. 12 adjoins the Blakely homestead, where Blakely's mill stood (S-0080, as given in the place note). He also patented land in Secs. 26 and 35, T10S R66W, near Spring Valley in Douglas County, in 1870 and 1873 (S-0080).
When Colorado Springs was laid out he moved there and went into the lumber business, which he kept until 1879, when he moved to Leadville in the same trade (S-0059, p. 335). Walker and S. P. Gutshall had a lumber yard on Cucharas Street in Colorado Springs in 1875 (Colorado Springs Gazette, May 29, 1875, S-0198). Christopher Wilson worked for him in lumber 'at and above Colorado Springs' from 1872 and in 1874 took charge of a lumber yard for him at Pueblo (S-0059, p. 823). He married Essie Klinepeter on Dec. 25, 1878 (p. 335).
Charles M. Kirk recalled that the escaped prisoners Hall and Leighton were killed 'from ambush on the SP Gutshall Ranch,' then leased to his father, James E. Kirk; he dated it 1874 (Marr, Douglas County News, Feb. 22, 1973, S-0438), and Koch, who also has Kirk leasing the place in 1874, says the posse caught them on the S. P. Gutshall ranch (Koch, S-0197, p. 93). The newspapers put the killing in August 1875, at a corral near Blakesley's mill on West Cherry Creek (Rocky Mountain News, Aug. 8, 1875, S-0016); which of his tracts it was has not been settled. Find a Grave lists a Samuel Patterson Gutshall of Company C, 9th Pennsylvania Cavalry, born in 1840, who died at Denver on Jan. 11, 1909, and is buried in Evergreen Cemetery, Colorado Springs; it gives his birthplace as New Jersey, against the 1881 sketch, and links Isaac Gutshall as his brother (memorial 50091775, S-0440).
Places
- Blakely homestead and mill (Blakelyville): his 1870 land in Sec. 12 adjoins the Blakely homestead
Family
- Isaac Gutshall, brother
Sources
- S-0059: History of the Arkansas Valley, Colorado (O.L. Baskin & Co., Chicago, 1881) (online)
- S-0080: General Land Office land patents, Bureau of Land Management (glorecords.blm.gov)
- S-0198: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection: items on H. C. Blakely's mill and "Blakelyville" (1873-1885), J. W. Irion of Spring Valley (1870-75), and the Stout school (1905) (online)
- S-0438: Josephine Lowell Marr ("Mrs. John Marr"), local-history columns in The Douglas County News (Castle Rock), 1967–1976: "Douglas County History," "If Walls Could Speak" and "Walk With Our Pioneers," with the old newspaper items she reprinted (CHNC)
- S-0197: Susan E. (Steppler) Koch, The Land Is In My Blood: The History of The Divide Country and Its Pioneers, complete with Driving Tour and Homestead Maps (self-published; copyright 2015, U.S. Copyright Office TXu 2-251-186; first printing 2008, second October 2015, this copy the third printing, fall 2018)
- S-0016: Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection (coloradohistoricnewspapers.org)
- S-0440: Find a Grave (findagrave.com), grave memorial pages, cited by memorial number (online)
- Find a Grave, memorial 50091775
Every fact above names its source; numbers such as S-0246 refer to our source list. Find a Grave memorials are compiled by volunteers and are matched here only where their dates or family agree with the sources we have read.