Palmer Divide Research Project

David McShane (1830–1907)

Pioneer of 1860 who took up land at Monument in 1865, kept its first post office, built the stone round house of the 1868 raids and later the Monument Lake dam.

PeopleEl Paso County

Biography

David McShane was born on Oct. 3, 1830, nine miles south of Uniontown, Pennsylvania, a son of Barney McShane, a horse dealer, and Elizabeth Romine (Portrait and Biographical Record, 1899, S-0192, p. 1231). He farmed in Linn County, Iowa, from 1851, helped build the first house at Manhattan, Kansas, in 1855, and in 1860 came to Colorado with his brothers Francis and John C. By his own account their ox train was the first to cross the range into Summit County, where he placer-mined for four years in Humbug and American gulches, with a winter in the San Juan country with its first party of miners (p. 1231).

In the spring of 1865 he took up 160 acres 'three miles south of Palmer Lake,' and two years later brought his family from Iowa and went into the dairy and cattle business there (S-0192, pp. 1231-1232). His ranch became Monument's first post office, opened on April 8, 1869, with McShane as postmaster; his 1871 site report calls it 'McShane's Rancho,' in the NE1/4 of Sec. 15, T11S R67W (register via Bauer, S-0395; facsimile in Lavelett, S-0011, p. 33).

On Sept. 21, 1868 raiders came to the house while several women were alone there and took a picketed horse (Rocky Mountain News, Sept. 22, 1868). His own sketch says his wife, Catherine, frightened off twenty-three raiders with her gun, and that he then built a stone round house beside the house, with port holes and an underground passage, still standing in 1899 (S-0192, p. 1232). In the raids the families of the Divide 'forted up' at the McShane and Welty ranches (von Ahlefeldt, S-0009, p. 23).

A Democrat, he was elected an El Paso County commissioner in 1869, re-elected in 1872 and elected again in 1883; he was long a school director, and helped build Monument's first schoolhouse and two later ones (S-0192, p. 1232). In 1888 he moved to Colorado Springs and left the ranch to his son. As a contractor he built railroad grades, among them eight miles of the Colorado Midland, and ten reservoirs in El Paso County, and he found and developed the Bison mine at Cripple Creek (p. 1232). Monument Lake was one of his works: Monument people raised $30,000 in 1889 to buy the land from him, and on July 6, 1892 he turned the first furrow for the dam, with 75 men and 40 teams to follow (Rocky Mountain News, July 7, 1892, in Edwards, S-0233, p. 108).

Catherine died on April 10, 1898 (S-0192, p. 1232), and McShane on May 17, 1907. They are buried together in the Monument Cemetery under a stone with a Masonic emblem (Weinfeld and Howe, S-0183, p. 23; Find a Grave, memorial 140064644, S-0440). Their seven children included Laura, Mrs. George Newbrough, and Sarah, who married Frank Cotton of Colorado Springs (S-0192, p. 1232; McGrath, S-0200, vol. 1, pp. 293-294). Among the stock brands the Monument Mentor printed in 1878 is his, an M with a small raised c (von Ahlefeldt, S-0009, p. 41, read from the page image). Von Ahlefeldt counts the McShanes among the families of a fifteen-family wagon train from Iowa that settled near Monument in 1860, against his own sketch, which has him mining in Summit County for four years and taking up land three miles south of Palmer Lake in 1865 (S-0009, p. 22; Portrait and Biographical Record, 1899, S-0192, pp. 1231-1232).

Places

Family

Sources

  • S-0192: Portrait and Biographical Record of the State of Colorado (Chicago: Chapman Publishing Company, 1899) (online)
  • S-0395: William H. Bauer, Colorado Postal Encyclopedia: El Paso County, revised digital edition (Colorado Postal History Society, coloradopostalhistorysociety.com; revised by Steve Morehead, about 2017) (online)
  • S-0011: Lucille Lavelett, Through the Years at Monument, Colorado: The Story of Monument, Colorado, 5th printing (Palmer Lake: Palmer Lake Historical Society, 2004); first published Colorado Springs: Valliant Press, 1975
  • S-0009: Judy von Ahlefeldt, Thunder, Sun and Snow: The History of Colorado's Black Forest (Colorado Springs: Century One Press, a division of Graphic Services, Inc., 1979)
  • S-0233: Daniel W. Edwards, A Century of Railroading at Palmer Lake, 1871-1971 (Denver: the author, 2014; ISBN 978-1495478987)
  • S-0183: Michael Weinfeld and John Howe, Shootouts, Killings, and War Heroes: The History Hidden in Monument's Cemetery (Westcliffe, Colo.: Filter Press, 2024)
  • S-0440: Find a Grave (findagrave.com), grave memorial pages, cited by memorial number (online)
  • S-0200: Maria Davies McGrath, The Real Pioneers of Colorado, vols. 1-3 (Denver: Denver Museum, 1934; CWA Project No. 551), as retyped for the Denver Public Library Western History and Genealogy Department by Jane P. Ohl, October 2001
  • Find a Grave, memorial 140064644

Every fact above names its source; numbers such as S-0246 refer to our source list. Find a Grave memorials are compiled by volunteers and are matched here only where their dates or family agree with the sources we have read.

Know more about David McShane?

Corrections, family stories, photographs, deeds, letters and maps are all welcome. Messages and files come to Michael Christensen privately; nothing appears on the site until it has been checked, and you'll be credited the way you ask.