Palmer Divide Research Project

David C. Guire (1833–1902)

Monument rancher of the 1860s, west of town at 'Willow Grove,' who sold land for the town's reservoir and was killed by a train at Monument in 1902.

Also: David Caylor Guire · David Guire

PeopleEl Paso County

Biography

David C. Guire was born in Indiana on March 22, 1833, and grew up in Decatur County, Iowa (History of Colorado, 1919, S-0193, vol. 4, pp. 162-164). His biography brings him to Monument in 1862; family histories have him taking his homestead 'a mile west' of the town in the spring of 1864, after a winter on West Plum Creek, and the family's own account of 1960 has the Guires arriving in the spring of 1865 (S-0193; Kinner family histories, S-0199; Weinfeld and Howe, S-0183, p. 28). He held a homestead and a pre-emption claim, 320 acres in all, and in the raids of 1868 took part in the defense of the settlement (S-0193). He later sold 21 acres of his land for a reservoir (S-0193).

His first wife, Nancy Thorn, died in 1865 by his biography; a joint stone in the Monument Cemetery gives Nancie A. Guire's dates as Feb. 2, 1839 to Feb. 23, 1872 (S-0193; Weinfeld and Howe, S-0183, p. 31). He then married Mrs. Elizabeth Wise, the widow of Dr. C. H. Wise. A Democrat, he belonged to the Dunkard church and to the Masons at Colorado Springs (S-0193). His brother Henry died at his home in 1899 (Rocky Mountain News, Feb. 24, 1899, S-0393).

On July 23, 1902 he was killed 'while attempting to cross the railroad track' at Monument with his team and wagon, struck by a Rio Grande passenger train (Rocky Mountain News, July 24, 1902; Elbert County Banner, Aug. 15, 1902; S-0393). His widow sued the railroad for $5,000; the case was non-suited in March 1904 on the ground of contributory negligence (Colorado Daily Chieftain, March 11, 1904, S-0393). He is buried in the Monument Cemetery (Weinfeld and Howe, S-0183, p. 31; Find a Grave, memorial 81704840, S-0440).

Places

Family

Sources

  • S-0193: History of Colorado, illustrated, vols. 2-4, biographical (Chicago: S. J. Clarke Publishing Company, 1918 [vols. 2-3] and 1919 [vol. 4]), the set edited by Wilbur Fisk Stone (online)
  • S-0199: Larkspur Historical Society, the document store behind its "LHS Search Agent" (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org/resources/lhs-search-agents/): 362 files, about 810 MB, uploaded April–June 2026
  • S-0183: Michael Weinfeld and John Howe, Shootouts, Killings, and War Heroes: The History Hidden in Monument's Cemetery (Westcliffe, Colo.: Filter Press, 2024)
  • S-0393: The Guire family of Monument in the Colorado newspapers, 1873–1959 (CHNC)
  • S-0440: Find a Grave (findagrave.com), grave memorial pages, cited by memorial number (online)
  • Find a Grave, memorial 81704840

Every fact above names its source; numbers such as S-0246 refer to our source list. Find a Grave memorials are compiled by volunteers and are matched here only where their dates or family agree with the sources we have read.

Know more about David C. Guire?

Corrections, family stories, photographs, deeds, letters and maps are all welcome. Messages and files come to Michael Christensen privately; nothing appears on the site until it has been checked, and you'll be credited the way you ask.