# Phoebe Casteel (1870–1967)

- URL: https://palmerdivideresearch.com/people/phoebe-casteel/
- Also known as: Mrs. Phoebe Casteel; Mrs. Casteel
- Born March 16, 1870, Pulaski County, Indiana; died July 23, 1967, Colorado Springs, Colorado
- Updated: 2026-11-21

Wife of a Brentwood employee who opened a store and restaurant in her cabin on Black Forest Road in 1925, the Forest's second store.

## Biography

Phoebe Casteel, the wife of a Brentwood employee, opened a store and restaurant in her large cabin in 1925, soon after Mr. Utter opened the first store in the Forest at the Shoup-Black Forest crossroads; von Ahlefeldt places the cabin 'just south of the Black Forest intersection' (von Ahlefeldt, S-0009, p. 96). Rusk puts the store a quarter mile north of Shoup Road on Black Forest Road: a small cabin near her home where she sold non-perishable goods and never locked the door, leaving a note, 'help yourself, but close the door.' A permanent resident, she cooked twenty chicken dinners on many Sunday evenings for people who drove out to the Forest, kept boarders in her eight-room house, and rented a house across the road and cabins north of her own (Rusk, S-0012, p. 7). The 1976 county survey photographed the Casteel cabin, its stable and a log building 'likely a former store' at 12845 Black Forest Road, north of the crossroads, as Rusk has it (PPLD records of the survey, S-0101). By her daughter's account to von Ahlefeldt, she ran the store 'during the boom days of Brentwood in the 1920s' (S-0009, p. 124).

Rusk counts Mrs. Casteel among the probable first members of the Black Forest Ladies Club, formed in 1923, and in 1940 Mrs. Casteel's hooked rug, wool pillow top and crocheted buffet set went to the county fair at Calhan with the club's entries (S-0012, pp. 53-54). Find a Grave lists her as Phoebe Ann Degarimore Loving Hoover Casteel, born in Pulaski County, Indiana, on March 16, 1870, who died at Colorado Springs on July 23, 1967 (memorial 34464634, S-0440).

## Places

- Casteel cabin and store: her cabin, store and restaurant, from 1925 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/places/casteel-cabin-and-store/)

## Sources

- S-0009: Judy von Ahlefeldt, Thunder, Sun and Snow: The History of Colorado's Black Forest (Colorado Springs: Century One Press, a division of Graphic Services, Inc., 1979) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0009)
- S-0012: Vera Rusk Ellett, Growing Up in Black Forest ([Black Forest, Colo.]: the author, 1990) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0012)
- S-0101: Elaine Freed and David Barber, Historic Sites & Structures, El Paso County, Colorado ([Colorado Springs]: prepared for the El Paso County Land Use Department, [1977]), 56 pp., with the survey photographs in PPLD's Historic Sites and Structures collection (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0101)
- S-0440: Find a Grave (findagrave.com), grave memorial pages, cited by memorial number (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0440)
- Find a Grave, memorial 34464634: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/34464634

Compiled by Michael Christensen for the Palmer Divide Research Project. CC BY 4.0.