# J. George Benkelman (active 1862–1898)

- URL: https://palmerdivideresearch.com/people/j-george-benkelman/
- Also known as: John G. Benkelman; John George Benkelman; George John Benkelman; John B. Benkelman; John Benkelman; J. G. Benkelman; John C. Benkelman
- On record 1862–1898
- Updated: 2026-11-21

Württemberg-born cattleman and Denver capitalist who kept a cattle ranch on the Middle Kiowa from 1870 to 1876, and who as a Central City butcher was probably the John G. Benkelman whose camp on Dry Creek near Kiowa Station was raided on Aug. 25, 1868.

## Biography

J. George Benkelman was born in Württemberg, Germany, a son of Leonard and Daro (Stahl) Benkelman; his father was a stone cutter, mason and farmer. At twenty, in 1850, he sailed from Antwerp to New York, worked four years on a farm at Lancaster, N.Y., and in 1854 went to California by the Nicaragua route, prospecting and mining on the Yuba River for eight years. In the fall of 1861 he came back east by Panama, went on to Michigan, and in the spring of 1862 came to Colorado meaning to mine, but turned to the cattle business instead, first on a ranch on Turkey Creek (Portrait and Biographical Record, 1898, S-0191, p. 625; reprinted in Portrait and Biographical Record of the State of Colorado, 1899, S-0192, pp. 1395-1396). His son's sketch of 1918 has the family settling in Colorado in July 1862 (History of Colorado, vol. 2, 1918, S-0193, p. 372).

After a year on Turkey Creek he moved to Black Hawk, where he had a meat business, with a market in Central City as well (S-0191, p. 625). The coroner's inquest on Henrietta and John Dietermann, held at Denver on Aug. 27, 1868, heard 'John B. Benkelman,' who signed as John G. Benkelman, a butcher living at Central City: on Aug. 25 he and three companions were at their cabin on Dry Creek, about five miles below Kiowa Station, when raiders ran off some twenty-five horses, and he then joined the party that found the bodies (Rocky Mountain News, Aug. 27, 1868, S-0328). Broome, from a depredation claim filed by 'John Benkelman,' a Central City butcher with a cattle ranch near Kiowa, has him losing two horses and five head of cattle that morning, his house standing on the west side of Dry Creek (Broome, Cheyenne War, S-0340, pp. 367-369). The name, trade and town make this almost certainly the man of the 1898 sketch, which dates his Elbert County ranch only from 1870: that year he moved to Denver and 'started a cattle ranch on the Middle Kiowa,' which he kept until 1876 (S-0191, p. 625).

He then leased and later bought a large tract on the South Fork of the Republican in Cheyenne County, Kansas, where he ran ten to twelve thousand head and shipped two trains of thirty-three cars to Chicago each fall (S-0191, p. 625). Anton Schindelholz, another Elbert County cattleman, wrote that he sold his own ranch on the south branch of the Republican to 'George John Benkelman' (S-0191, p. 520). Benkelman retired in 1883 and was an active member of the Colorado Cattle Growers' Association and a director and investor in the Colorado Packing and Provision Company; from December 1871 he lived at California and Eighteenth streets in Denver. He was a Republican, and the family belonged to the English Lutheran Church (S-0191, pp. 625-626). He was a director of the Colorado Savings Bank of Denver, incorporated in 1887 (Hall, S-0058, vol. 3, p. 216).

In December 1861, at Sturgis, Mich., he married Christine Romel, born near Stuttgart; in 1898 they had three living sons, among them George W. of the Colorado Packing and Provision Company and Harry J., a former deputy secretary of state (S-0191, pp. 625-626). The son's 1918 sketch names the parents John G. and Christina (Rommel) Benkelman, says they were married at Buffalo, calls the father one of the organizers of the Colorado Packing Company, and says his last days were spent in Denver, where his wife also died (S-0193, vol. 2, p. 372). McGrath's 'John C. and Catherine Benkelman,' who crossed the plains in 1860, are plainly the same couple, since their son George W. was born on Turkey Creek on Sept. 23, 1862; McGrath adds that the town of Benkelman, Nebraska, was named for the family and that George W. died on Dec. 28, 1926 (McGrath, S-0200, vol. 1, p. 92).

## Places

- Kiowa: his cattle ranch on the Middle Kiowa, 1870-76 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/places/kiowa/)
- Dietemann killings (Aug. 25, 1868): probably the inquest witness of 1868, whose Dry Creek camp was raided that morning (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/places/dietemann-killings-aug-25-1868/)

## Sources

- S-0191: Portrait and Biographical Record of Denver and Vicinity, Colorado (Chicago: Chapman Publishing Company, 1898) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0191)
- S-0192: Portrait and Biographical Record of the State of Colorado (Chicago: Chapman Publishing Company, 1899) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0192)
- S-0193: History of Colorado, illustrated, vols. 2-4, biographical (Chicago: S. J. Clarke Publishing Company, 1918 [vols. 2-3] and 1919 [vol. 4]), the set edited by Wilbur Fisk Stone (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0193)
- S-0328: CHNC check of Broome's Hungate (1864) and 1868-war claims (newspapers, 2026-10-28) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0328)
- S-0340: Jeff Broome, Cheyenne War: Indian Raids on the Roads to Denver, 1864–1869 (Sheridan, Colo.: Aberdeen Books; Sterling: Logan County Historical Society, 2013), ISBN 978-0-9713852-4-5 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0340)
- S-0058: Frank Hall, History of the State of Colorado, vol. 3 (1891) and vol. 4 (1895) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0058)
- S-0200: Maria Davies McGrath, The Real Pioneers of Colorado, vols. 1-3 (Denver: Denver Museum, 1934; CWA Project No. 551), as retyped for the Denver Public Library Western History and Genealogy Department by Jane P. Ohl, October 2001 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0200)
- Portrait and Biographical Record of Denver and Vicinity (1898), p. 625, the biographical sketch (page scan): https://archive.org/details/biographportrait00chaprich/page/625/mode/2up
- Portrait and Biographical Record of Denver and Vicinity (1898), p. 519, named in the sketch of Anton Schindelholz (page scan): https://archive.org/details/biographportrait00chaprich/page/519/mode/2up

Compiled by Michael Christensen for the Palmer Divide Research Project. CC BY 4.0.