# David C. Guire (1833–1902)

- URL: https://palmerdivideresearch.com/people/david-c-guire/
- Also known as: David Caylor Guire; David Guire
- Born March 22, 1833, Indiana; died July 23, 1902, Monument, Colorado
- Updated: 2026-11-21

Monument rancher of the 1860s, west of town at 'Willow Grove,' who sold land for the town's reservoir and was killed by a train at Monument in 1902.

## Biography

David C. Guire was born in Indiana on March 22, 1833, and grew up in Decatur County, Iowa (History of Colorado, 1919, S-0193, vol. 4, pp. 162-164). His biography brings him to Monument in 1862; family histories have him taking his homestead 'a mile west' of the town in the spring of 1864, after a winter on West Plum Creek, and the family's own account of 1960 has the Guires arriving in the spring of 1865 (S-0193; Kinner family histories, S-0199; Weinfeld and Howe, S-0183, p. 28). He held a homestead and a pre-emption claim, 320 acres in all, and in the raids of 1868 took part in the defense of the settlement (S-0193). He later sold 21 acres of his land for a reservoir (S-0193).

His first wife, Nancy Thorn, died in 1865 by his biography; a joint stone in the Monument Cemetery gives Nancie A. Guire's dates as Feb. 2, 1839 to Feb. 23, 1872 (S-0193; Weinfeld and Howe, S-0183, p. 31). He then married Mrs. Elizabeth Wise, the widow of Dr. C. H. Wise. A Democrat, he belonged to the Dunkard church and to the Masons at Colorado Springs (S-0193). His brother Henry died at his home in 1899 (Rocky Mountain News, Feb. 24, 1899, S-0393).

On July 23, 1902 he was killed 'while attempting to cross the railroad track' at Monument with his team and wagon, struck by a Rio Grande passenger train (Rocky Mountain News, July 24, 1902; Elbert County Banner, Aug. 15, 1902; S-0393). His widow sued the railroad for $5,000; the case was non-suited in March 1904 on the ground of contributory negligence (Colorado Daily Chieftain, March 11, 1904, S-0393). He is buried in the Monument Cemetery (Weinfeld and Howe, S-0183, p. 31; Find a Grave, memorial 81704840, S-0440).

## Places

- David C. Guire homestead: his homestead west of Monument (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/places/david-c-guire-homestead/)
- Monument Lake dam (1889-1892): sold 21 acres for a reservoir, by his biography (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/places/monument-lake-dam-1889-1892/)
- Monument Cemetery: buried here, 1902 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/places/monument-cemetery/)

## Family

- Henry Guire, brother (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/people/henry-guire/)
- Joseph Guire, father (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/people/joseph-guire/)
- Jacob Guire, brother (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/people/jacob-guire/)
- Josiah M. Guire, brother (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/people/josiah-m-guire/)

## Sources

- S-0193: History of Colorado, illustrated, vols. 2-4, biographical (Chicago: S. J. Clarke Publishing Company, 1918 [vols. 2-3] and 1919 [vol. 4]), the set edited by Wilbur Fisk Stone (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0193)
- S-0199: Larkspur Historical Society, the document store behind its "LHS Search Agent" (larkspurhistoricalsociety.org/resources/lhs-search-agents/): 362 files, about 810 MB, uploaded April–June 2026 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0199)
- S-0183: Michael Weinfeld and John Howe, Shootouts, Killings, and War Heroes: The History Hidden in Monument's Cemetery (Westcliffe, Colo.: Filter Press, 2024) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0183)
- S-0393: The Guire family of Monument in the Colorado newspapers, 1873–1959 (CHNC) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0393)
- S-0440: Find a Grave (findagrave.com), grave memorial pages, cited by memorial number (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0440)
- Find a Grave, memorial 81704840: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/81704840

Compiled by Michael Christensen for the Palmer Divide Research Project. CC BY 4.0.