# Catherine McShane (1836–1898)

- URL: https://palmerdivideresearch.com/people/catherine-mcshane/
- Also known as: Catherine Willyard; Mrs. David McShane
- Born May 25, 1836, Fayette County, Pennsylvania; died April 10, 1898, Colorado Springs, Colorado
- Updated: 2026-11-21

Wife of David McShane, remembered for facing down raiders at the McShane ranch near Monument in September 1868.

## Biography

Catherine Willyard, a daughter of Allen Willyard, was born in Fayette County, Pennsylvania, and married David McShane in Iowa (Portrait and Biographical Record, 1899, S-0192, p. 1232); Find a Grave gives her birth as May 25, 1836, at Fayette City (memorial 140064676, S-0440). In 1867 she came west with their children to his ranch south of Palmer Lake, the McShane home at Monument (S-0192, pp. 1231-1232).

She is remembered for the raid of September 1868. The Rocky Mountain News of Sept. 22 reported that raiders came to the McShane house, where 'several women' were alone, and took a picketed horse after Mrs. McShane told them to. Her husband's 1899 sketch has her frightening off twenty-three raiders with her gun, and Carl Mathews's account of 1969 tells it the same way (S-0192, p. 1232; Mathews, S-0020, p. 27). Broome prints her own account of the raid (Broome, S-0340, p. 387).

She died on April 10, 1898, and is buried with her husband in the Monument Cemetery (S-0192, p. 1232; Weinfeld and Howe, S-0183, p. 23; Find a Grave, memorial 140064676, S-0440). Her husband's sketch calls her 'a woman of brave, noble character' (S-0192, p. 1232). Von Ahlefeldt gives another version of the raid of 1868, as old-timers handed it down: alone with the children, Mrs. McShane saw raiders lurking behind a haystack, hid the children and pointed her husband's rifle at the riders each time they passed, until the rifle went off by accident and scared them away, though not before they had taken the McShane horses (von Ahlefeldt, S-0009, p. 23).

## Places

- McShane Home: her home from 1867 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/places/mcshane-home/)
- McShane's stone fort: the raid of Sept. 21, 1868 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/places/mcshanes-stone-fort/)
- Monument Cemetery: buried here, 1898 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/places/monument-cemetery/)

## Family

- David McShane, husband (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/people/david-mcshane/)

## Sources

- S-0192: Portrait and Biographical Record of the State of Colorado (Chicago: Chapman Publishing Company, 1899) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0192)
- S-0440: Find a Grave (findagrave.com), grave memorial pages, cited by memorial number (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0440)
- S-0020: Carl F. Mathews and E.C. Matthews, Early Days Around the Divide (St. Louis: Sign Book Co., [1969]), 78 p., illus., map, ports. (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0020)
- S-0340: Jeff Broome, Cheyenne War: Indian Raids on the Roads to Denver, 1864–1869 (Sheridan, Colo.: Aberdeen Books; Sterling: Logan County Historical Society, 2013), ISBN 978-0-9713852-4-5 (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0340)
- S-0183: Michael Weinfeld and John Howe, Shootouts, Killings, and War Heroes: The History Hidden in Monument's Cemetery (Westcliffe, Colo.: Filter Press, 2024) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0183)
- S-0009: Judy von Ahlefeldt, Thunder, Sun and Snow: The History of Colorado's Black Forest (Colorado Springs: Century One Press, a division of Graphic Services, Inc., 1979) (https://palmerdivideresearch.com/sources/#s-0009)
- Find a Grave, memorial 140064676: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/140064676

Compiled by Michael Christensen for the Palmer Divide Research Project. CC BY 4.0.